At this time, Hamano had to admit that the lawyer named Kitahara was indeed somewhat competent. If the city hall he represented was not the party with a natural advantage, then the outcome of this case would really depend on it.

Suspense. But unfortunately, you are destined to lose today!

Hamano also noticed that the collusive bidding situations mentioned by Kitahara, such as the relationship between the presidents being husband and wife, and the shared deposit account, can actually explain these anomalies through subsequent supplementary explanations. In other words, these are still

Not conclusive evidence.

Indeed, this lawyer is very talented at digging out the facts of the case.

But that’s where it ends.

Without decisive evidence, the case can only be lost.

Hamano still didn't believe that Kitahara could come up with the final material. Even if he talked about eight or ten more projects, they would all be the same.

In the next second, Beihara's voice was heard saying, "Next, I will represent the parties concerned and accuse the High-tech Industrial Park of colluding in the third project of bidding."

At this moment, the mood of the city hall officials present became highly tense again. After the first two accusations of collusion in bidding, they were not sure whether Kitahara would tell more explosive scandals and situations. Although, these officials understood

They can supplement the information as Hamano said, but even so, at this moment they are tightly held by the Kitahara lawyer's every move.

They, a group of middle-aged and elderly people, seemed to have been forced onto a roller coaster by this lawyer, feeling the intense tension of jumping up and down.

Kitahara seemed to feel the nervousness of the people present, and there was a hint of cynicism in their expressions.

He said: "The High-tech Industrial Park is inviting bids for smart access control systems. In the last round of bid evaluation for this project, three companies were shortlisted. In the end, one won the bid and two failed. The winning bidder was Shengrong Mechanical and Electrical Co., Ltd., which was unsuccessful.

The other two companies are Xiaguang Industrial Co., Ltd. and Gaoyuan Engineering Co., Ltd."

Beihara took out three thick books from the table behind him.

"These are the bids submitted by three companies for this project," the male lawyer said.

Hamano saw that there seemed to be no other materials on the other party's table, only these three bids, so he deliberately sarcastically said, "Lawyer Kitahara, what's the point of handing in these three bids? Is it possible that these three companies will put them

How to collude in bidding, is it written in the bidding document?!"

"Of course. They wrote it." Beihara replied abruptly.

Perhaps they didn't expect that the lawyer in front of them would respond to Hamano like this. Everyone in the conference room was stunned for a moment. How could the company admit in the bid document that it was colluding with the bid.

"Are you kidding?!" Hamano was irritated by this frivolous answer, "This is a serious case trial!! Please explain it clearly to me!!"

Beiyuan picked up the bidding documents one by one, "This is the bidding document produced by Shengrong Mechanical and Electrical Co., Ltd. Please turn the bidding document to page 192. This page talks about the installation plan of face recognition access control. The bidding document of Xiaguang Industrial Co., Ltd.

Page 203 and page 209 of Gaoyuan Engineering Co., Ltd.’s tender document also contain the content of facial recognition access control.”

Later, Beiyuan pointed to a paragraph in the bid document and suddenly said in surprise, "Hey! It's really strange! Why does this paragraph, with 506 words, appear intact in the bid documents of the other two clubs, with the sentences broken?

The punctuation marks are all exactly the same. Please tell me what’s going on.”

The words fell.

Suddenly, a shocking wave arose!

There are exactly the same paragraphs in the three tender documents?!

Hamano couldn't believe it. He immediately flipped through the three bid documents and located the paragraph that Kitahara said. When he opened it, he found that it was really the same! Three bid documents, three different companies, but when making the bid documents, they were actually different.

A paragraph with exactly the same text appears.

This shows that the makers of the tender documents are the same person.

Moreover, they lazily copied and pasted each other's content.

This is simply irrefutable proof!

Hard evidence of bid collusion!

The important officials of the city hall were sitting in their seats, and they were also stunned. The tender documents for one project had hundreds or even thousands of pages. The total number of tender documents for different projects and different companies amounted to tens of thousands of pages of materials. This lawyer

How did you do it?! How did you find this small identical paragraph among tens of thousands of pages of materials!!

This is the devil!

This is a monster!!

Hamano found that his palms were sweating. He carefully read the repeated words in the bid document. If the city hall could supplement materials before, then it was impossible to produce materials to correct the repeated paragraphs in the bid document in front of him.

illustrative.

However, one must fight back.

Otherwise, you really lose!

What should I say?!

The public lawyer was reading the text in front of him, his brain working rapidly. Hamano's extremely rich trial and legal experience still provided him with help at the most critical moment.

After carefully reading the text, Hamano formed a counter-strategy and stood up and said: "This point you pointed out is not true. The repeated paragraphs are not a unique explanation of the access control technology solution. It is just an introduction to the market.

It’s just an existing face recognition solution. For this kind of introductory text, it’s entirely possible that it was copied and pasted from information on the Internet, so it’s not surprising if there are duplications!”

After all, he is a public lawyer who has fought in the High Court.

In an instant, he made an extremely powerful counterattack again.

However, after Hamano said these words, he saw Kitahara's eyes.

He couldn't forget this look.

This look is like the look of a ferocious hunter covered in thick fur in the forest. After carefully setting a trap, he hides in the dark to observe his prey.

For a moment, the public lawyer actually felt scared.

Yes, just because of this look, he was trembling with fear.

This was something he had never experienced in his decades of court experience.

In this short second, he felt that he had fallen into the opponent's trap. Although he didn't know what the trap was and what kind of terrifying device it contained. However, he felt that he had stepped into it and would be trapped in the next second.

The sharp steel teeth inside severely penetrated the clamp, causing blood to drip from it.

Beihara took out a piece of paper.

The young man in a gray suit said, "This is an IP address query form. After applying, we retrieved the email address used to receive bids for the bidding project. The email company reported the email addresses of the three companies involved in sending bids.

IP address."

"The IP addresses that sent these three emails are all the same," the male lawyer said calmly.

Everyone in the conference room froze

The IP addresses of the bidding emails from the three companies are the same.
Chapter completed!