Even Liu Xiang himself was stunned. He had said this before and even begged him, but no one believed him. They just asked him to bear the consequences of this and pursue the punishment, but he could not afford the consequences at all. As for the punishment, he did not have the ability to pay any fines. This was also the reason why he asked after seeing Liu Xiaotian whether he would go to jail.

In his heart, he was already planning to face the worst consequences.

The tone of his previous speech was also full of grievance, which was more like sarcasm. He asked if you believe it, but he knew in his heart that no one would believe what he said.

So, Liu Xiaotian's answer made him stunned.

"You really believe what I said?"

After a while, Liu Xiang asked back, and Liu Xiaotian nodded again. Believe that he believed what Liu Xiang said, and that was true.

First of all, if Liu Xiang sells counterfeit goods, he would not only sell this time. Liu Xiang does not sell particularly valuable items, but only some household items. This time the buyer bought so many of them in one go. If Liu Xiang sold counterfeit goods for the first time, he would not dare to sell so many.

If it wasn't for the first time, he would have sold it many times before. The profit of selling fakes as real ones is definitely very high. Even if he doesn't sell much and is less timid, he will not be able to live like this.

Another point, the most important point is that the grievance and helplessness when Liu Xiang said these things just now cannot be pretended. At least it cannot be pretended to be in front of Liu Xiaotian. Even if the lie master does not want to lie in front of Liu Xiaotian now. Liu Xiaotian can sensitively feel the other person's heartbeat, even every subtle movement.

When a person lies, his body will inevitably have unnatural reactions. These reactions are not controlled by individuals, but human instincts. Liu Xiaotian has specially studied these things. Now he is a good psychological expert. According to his observation just now, Liu Xiang did not have any lying reactions, which shows that he was telling the truth and was really wronged.

"I believe, absolutely, but only I believe is useless. If you want to cleanse your grievances, we must find out the truth and publish it so that everyone will believe in you. I am a lawyer, not a policeman, but I am responsible for this case. I have the responsibility and obligation to make my client receive the most fair treatment. This means that we have a common goal. I want to clear the grievances of the company. You have to do for yourself, I believe in you, so you have to believe in me."

Liu Xiaotian said slowly, his tone was unhappy and his voice was steady, giving people a great sense of convincing.

With his sincere eyes, sincere attitude, and his higher temperament than others, he gives people a sense of nobility and makes people believe him unnaturally. Liu Xiang has already nodded with his words.

Liu Xiang's attitude improved a lot, and he quickly told about this incident. From him, Liu Xiaotian heard a different version, which was completely different from the information brought by Pu Haitai.

Liu Xiang sells overseas skin care products and some health care equipment. Because these things are extremely easy to fake, and the profit after fraud is extremely high, his shop has always been the focus of the company. He is very clear about the consequences of selling fakes, so he has never done this. Last year, he also received the company's integrity medal.

Liu Xiangren is already middle-aged. Logically speaking, he has such a business. Even if his life is not very good, he can live completely. He should not live in a warehouse like he is now, and there is no problem with having a simple and comfortable cottage.

It is not hundreds of years ago, with inflated housing prices, 30 printing technology continues to mature, and the development of technology, the cost of houses is now very low, which is even lower than before. With the continuous regulation of the country, the current housing prices are not particularly high.

Compared with his low housing prices, it is fine to buy one, not to mention renting a house, but Liu Xiang's life is obviously very ordinary at first glance. Liu Xiang didn't say these things, but Liu Xiaotian finally asked.

Liu Xiang's son committed a crime three years ago and was imprisoned and fined a lot of money. Liu Xiang wanted his son to come out early, so he had to pay all the fines early. He has been saving money in recent years and allowed himself to live in the worst conditions, just to save money to let his son come out early, and the same is true for his mother.

This is also one of the reasons why the company believes that he sells fake goods. Because he is short of money and needs money, a father can do anything when he wants to save his son. After the company learns the news, he doesn't believe him at all and always blames him. Liu Xiaotian is the first person to believe him and is willing to listen to his explanation.

"You mean, he did buy a batch of goods from you, and what you sold him was genuine, but later he told the mall that these were fakes, and that the batch of goods that he proved were fakes, all of them were batches of your products, and there was also a shopping mall inspection form."

After hearing this, Liu Xiaotian's eyebrows were already condensed and he asked in a low voice.

"That's true. If it weren't for this, people in the mall wouldn't have completely distrust me. After all, I have been in this mall for many years and have a good reputation. Unfortunately, I have also implicated Technician Wang this time."

Liu Xiang said slowly with a bitter face. Technician Wang was a staff member who specialized in the inspection and sales of goods in Ocean Department Store. Liu Xiang's goods must enter the mall and sell them. He will only be allowed to leave it here. Now Technician Wang has been suspended at home. As for whether he accepted Liu Xiang's bribes, he will have to investigate next. If such behavior occurs, he will not be as simple as dereliction of duty and may be arrested.

"I understand, Mr. Liu, my surname is Liu, and we are still our own family. Please be sure to believe me. As long as you are innocent, I will definitely help you find your innocence. I need a detailed written summary of this matter. I hope you can write it out and hand it over to me directly, and don't go through other people."

Liu Xiaotian stood up. He had already understood here and achieved his goal. It was time to say goodbye.

"Don't worry, I will definitely do it"

Liu Xiang hurriedly agreed and sent Liu Xiaotian and the others out. Before leaving, Liu Xiaotian asked for the phone number of technician Wang and then left.

Seeing them leaving, Liu Xiang sighed heavily and went back to comfort his mother. This was another heavy blow to his mother. A few years ago, her favorite grandson was suddenly imprisoned, and now her son is facing prison again. When will this family of disasters be spared from these disasters?

"Lawyer Liu, you are still good at it. I asked everything directly, but I don't believe what he said. There must be some truth or falsehood in his words. I think it's him who colluded with the technician to sell fake goods for profit."

After going out, Zhang Yang said excitedly. He thought that Liu Xiaotian deliberately stabilized Liu Xiang, deceived him, and asked him to say all this. Although it was as Liu Xiang himself said, they also got a lot of useful clues from it.

"What did you say? The facts have not been clarified yet. How did you conclude that he was selling fake goods?"

Liu Xiaotian suddenly stopped, frowned and asked, and stared at Zhang Yang straight there. Zhang Yang felt a little guilty when he saw him, and he couldn't help but lower his head.

"I'm not sure, isn't this what Ocean Department Store said? They will definitely not be willing to admit such a mistake. Since they all admit it, it must be a fact."

Zhang Yang's voice became smaller and smaller, and in the end he could hardly hear it.

"Zhang Yang, I didn't deceive him. Although some lawyers deliberately deceive others in order to collect evidence, I have never done this before, and we don't need to do this. Before becoming a lawyer, first of all, you have to remember clearly. We are human beings, upright people, and even people can't do well, so don't be lawyers. I like these words that you can remember and truly remember."

Liu Xiaotian said something peaceful, but every word was like a stick and hit Zhang Yang. Zhang Yang's face turned pale. He first saw Liu Xiaotian so serious.

"Lawyer Liu, I, I know I'm wrong."

Zhang Yang hurriedly admitted his mistake. He knew very well that following Liu Xiaotian had made many people envious of the law firm and he wanted someone to replace him. Following the law firm with the most experienced and promising lawyer is also a help and improvement for individuals.

Not to mention those new employees, even the old employees in the past envy him. Even some formal lawyers have said that they are willing to follow Liu Xiaotian and learn from him.

"No next time"

After Liu Xiaotian said this, he walked forward directly. Zhang Yang was a little stunned and a cold sweat broke out from his body. He didn't expect that Lawyer Liu attached so much importance to this matter and even warned him directly.

This also made him pay more attention to Liu Xiaotian's words just now and remember them carefully to avoid making such mistakes in the future.

In a cafe, Liu Xiaotian made an appointment with technician Wang. Technician Wang is a young man, 25 years old this year. His full name is Wang Changshun. According to Liu Xiaotian's age, they are still people of the same age, and Liu Xiaotian is a little older than him.

Wang Changshun's face was also very haggard. His name was Changshun, but it was indeed very unsuccessful now. Liu Xiang's counterfeit case involved him. The company believed that he had benefited from Liu Xiang from top to bottom. It might even be that he was selling counterfeit goods together. He couldn't even explain it clearly and no one listened to it.

In particular, someone took out a video and saw clearly that he and Liu Xiang were talking and laughing into a good restaurant, which made people even more convinced that this was a fact.

He did go to dinner with Liu Xiang. Liu Xiang's goods had to be inspected by him. It was normal to bring him some food occasionally or invite him to have a meal. Moreover, the restaurant looked good and the price was not high. The two of them had a simple lunch, which was a simple meal.

But when he was taken out at this time, the meaning was completely different. He has become more passive and depressed now.

Liu Xiaotian is a lawyer in the company, and he knows a little bit about this. After all, he is also an employee of the company. He knows that the legal department has changed his legal counsel and changed to a law firm. This law firm also has a very young and powerful lawyer. However, he only heard that this is the first time he has seen this rumored young lawyer.

The first time we met, it was still in this case.

Liu Xiaotian asked him about the contents of his company completely different from those in the previous company. He asked more about his position operations and how to verify the inspection form. Unlike the company's people, they asked him how much benefits he received, why he helped Liu Xiang sell fake goods, the company treats him well, why did he damage the company's reputation, etc.

This also made him feel a little better, and he answered questions and cooperated very well with Liu Xiaotian.

The two chatted for about twenty minutes, and Liu Xiaotian said goodbye and left. The information he wanted to know here was almost the same. There was no need to continue asking. He also comforted technician Wang, saying that he would definitely figure out this matter, let everyone know the truth and not have any psychological burden.

"Lawyer Liu, how are you doing?"

On the car back, Zhang Yang asked carefully. As a lawyer who failed even the judicial examination, Liu Xiaotian's warning to him before was very powerful, and he had to be careful.

"This case is more complicated than we imagined. This is not a simple case of selling counterfeits and fighting counterfeiting. There are likely other conspiracies in it, and there must be insiders in Ocean Department Store, who are both inside and outside to frame them."

Liu Xiaotian shook his head slightly. He didn't think so much about the case at the beginning. Pu Haitai told him that the company had admitted its mistake and was just negotiating compensation. His task was to reduce the losses of Ocean Department Store to a lower level, rather than to think about helping them win the lawsuit.

Such a lawsuit cannot be won. It is a victory to recover part of the losses and reduce the compensation amount.

"So, what they said is true. Someone here has tampered with it?"

Zhang Yang was stunned again. Although Liu Xiaotian's warning was still difficult to make him fully believe Liu Xiaotian's words. After all, he had preconceived these things.

"That's true. There is still time in the afternoon. You can make an appointment with the plaintiff to see if you can meet him, and then talk about the issue of compensation."

Liu Xiaotian thought for a while and then gave an order. Zhang Yang immediately contacted the plaintiff, the customer who bought the goods. The customer didn't even hire a lawyer. He had a conclusive evidence in the lawsuit he filed. Such a lawsuit was basically won, so there was no need to hire a lawyer to spend more money.

The other party readily accepted his meeting request, and Liu Xiaotian also met the plaintiff very quickly.

A thin man of thirty-five or six years old looked a little quiet. Liu Xiaotian didn't say anything nonsense to him. He directly talked to him about compensation according to Pu Haitai's request. Oceanwide Company was willing to double the compensation and hoped to settle out of court. This request was flatly rejected by the other party. The plaintiff insisted that he had to pay ten times the compensation, otherwise it would be seen in court.

Liu Xiaotian noticed that when he talked about ten times compensation, he was always a little excited.

"Mr. Gao, I will convey your meaning to the company's upper class, but personally, the possibility of their agreement is very low."

Liu Xiaotian looked at the other party and said slowly that the plaintiff was named Gao Shi. According to the information, he worked in a chemical factory and was not a professional anti-counterfeiting person. This was also his first time buying counterfeiting.

The so-called buying fakes and fighting counterfeiting means that even though they know it is a fake, they still buy a lot of things, and then sue the goods as fakes and obtain multiple compensation benefits. This industry has never disappeared since its appearance. Now there is a professional team of buying fakes and fighting counterfeiting, with someone visiting the door to check what things may be fake, and then someone checks out the spots, and finally someone goes to buy them.

Some buy in small batches first, gain trust, and then buy in large batches, while others buy in large batches directly. However, now people who sell fakes are smart. There are really inexplicable large order customers who don’t sell on the grounds that there is no stock, and these are the people who are worried about it.

The attitude towards such people is supported, so as long as there is such a lawsuit, the anti-counterfeiting will basically win, and this will also have the purpose of cracking down on counterfeit goods. Even if you escape scrutiny, you will have to bear more economic risks, which will increase the cost of selling counterfeit goods. Over time, naturally no one will come to sell counterfeit goods.

Such people have common characteristics. Teams, when they buy things, sue them immediately, waiting for you to negotiate, and then settle out of court. Generally speaking, compensation can be negotiated. After all, settlement outside court saves time. Even if the other party will definitely lose, it will take some time to execute it.

For them, the most important purpose is to make money, and it only depends on negotiations. These people have very high negotiation skills.

Gao Shi is obviously different from them. Gao Shi only has one person, not a team, and he is not good at negotiating skills. He always sees him in court and insists on ten times of compensation without giving up at all. It seems that he will definitely pay this number after he has made a decision. He doesn't care that he has to wait for the court to make a judgment before he can get the money.

"Mr. Gao, I'll take the initiative to ask a question, do you know anyone in Ocean Department Store?"

Liu Xiaotian suddenly asked, this was a question that had nothing to do with the case. Gao Shi was stunned by his question and immediately shook his head: "No, how could I have anyone?"

"Okay, I understand. Thank you Mr. Gao for your cooperation. I will continue to mediate and convey your opinions to the company."

Liu Xiaotian stood up and stood up to say goodbye. Gao Shi was a little panicked just now, but now he has recovered. He got up and sent Liu Xiaotian and the others away.

Gao Shi was lying. Liu Xiaotian was sure of this. He must have known people at Ocean Department Store, and it is very likely that he was the insider. Technician Wang said that their review was not particularly strict, especially for those merchants who had been working for a long time, which was basically a formality.

He is not just a technician at Oceanwide Department Store. In fact, his review is the strictest. He will check it carefully every time and will only be released after confirmation.

The inspection orders of Ocean Department Store are the same, but different people stamp different seals. This means that as long as someone can get Technician Wang's seal, they can create such inspection orders. According to Technician Wang's own recollection, he does not care about the management of these official seals. They are placed in the office and rarely locked.

This kind of official seal can only be used by reviewing other people's products. It has no use when taken out, so he doesn't care.

If this is the case, it is equivalent to giving someone the possibility of forging the inspection form.

Even if the inspection form can be forged, the possibility of various other things being forged is greater, and just a few health products are easier to forge.

"Go to Ocean Department Store"

In the car, Liu Xiaotian suddenly ordered that he went to Ocean Department Store. This matter was not that simple. If you want to investigate the facts clearly, you still need a lot of evidence. He is just guessing now that there is not even a specific candidate. Ocean Department Store still needs to go there.

Ocean Department Store attaches great importance to this matter. This is the first time they have been targeted by people who have been counterfeited in several years. They really bought counterfeit goods from them. The whole company was very annoyed. After several meetings, they were finally willing to agree to Gao Shi’s request, willing to pay ten times the compensation, and settle out of court. They were unwilling to make up the matter.

Unfortunately, things didn't go as expected. They just made a decision and could notify Gao Shi, who had already found a reporter and exposed the incident on their own initiative.

For a time, negative news from the media came overwhelmingly, and the company began to suffer economic losses.
To be continued...