Font
Large
Medium
Small
Night
Prev Index    Favorite Next

Chapter 202 Who is lying

"The defense believes that using body fluid to detect blood type is not accurate, and this result cannot be used as evidence. As for shoe size, there are many men wearing the same shoe size and cannot be isolated evidence." Yao Wu said.

Yuan Dan pursed her lips tightly, and the anger in her eyes could not be concealed. She had seen many lawyers who were tit-for-tat in court, but had never seen such a slander.

"Defense Attorney, in your opinion, what can be evidence?" Yuan Dan asked.

"Of course it is extracted on the spot and can match the suspect." Yao Wuyan snorted.

"According to your theory, as long as you can't catch it on the spot, you can just shirke it all?"

"I didn't say that, but the evidence in this case is very far-fetched and unfair to the defendant." Yao Wuyan refused to give in.

"Don't argue." Fang Chaoyang knocked on the gavel to stop the two of them from arguing.

Yuan Dan paused for a moment and showed the next evidence. Shang Zaijun's diagnosis in the hospital's psychiatric department. For this diagnosis, the police took a long time to find it from the piles of medical records.

The diagnosis document contains the doctor's record. Shang Zaijun himself said that he felt something was wrong with his mental state just now, and he couldn't sleep well every day, and his body would suffer from inexplicable pain.

This diagnosis proves that he went to the hospital five years ago, not long after Yu Qing was killed.

It seems that this evidence is beneficial to Shang Zaijun, proving that he suffers from mental disorders, so Shang Zaijun just took a look and said that he saw clearly and had no objection.

The evidence came to the defense lawyer, but Chi Weiran frowned and immediately expressed his objection.

"The defense believes that this diagnosis only shows that the defendant was in poor mental state when he was in the treatment and could not prove that he had no problems with his mental state before." Chi Weiran said.

"Defense Attorney, how do you determine that the defendant had a problem with his mental state before? What about the evidence?" Yuan Dan was so angry that this statement seemed to be unreasonable.

"I am just explaining that the diagnosis cannot reflect the past situation. The defendant was under tremendous pressure because of his father's humiliation, which may lead to mental breakdown." Chi Weiran said.

The card of mental disorders is something that the lawyers must play.

Fang Chaoyang understood why Chi Weiran held on to this matter. If this diagnosis was established, then if the deaths of Wu Lanfang and Yu Qing were found out, it would be that Shang Zaijun was in a normal state of mind. These two serious crimes alone would not be able to escape the death penalty.

"Defense, please do not use inference words. Perhaps, as you say, everyone may have mental disorders." Yuan Dan said.

"I didn't say everyone, you are amplifying the impact of this word." Chi Weiran said.

In terms of language skills, Yuan Dan had already lost a game. Fang Chaoyang stopped the two of them and said, "Public prosecutor, please continue to show evidence."

Yuan Dan took out another mental appraisal report. This was a certificate issued by an authoritative organization after Shang Zaijun was arrested. It showed that Shang Zaijun did suffer from depression, but no organic lesions were seen and he had normal behavioral ability.

As for the current trial format, this report is crucial, proving that everything Shang Zaijun did was carried out in a state of sane, so his confession during the trial was also valid.

After reading the evidence, Shang Zaijun said that he had seen it clearly, but raised objections, saying that the appraisal result was not true. He often had a confused mind and could not remember everything he did.

Yuan Dan sneered at the defense lawyer team opposite him to see how they overturned the appraisal certificate.

"The presiding judge, the defense party believes that this appraisal report can only prove the defendant's mental condition during the inspection process and cannot reflect the mental condition of a certain period in the past. I hope the court will not adopt it." Chi Weiran said.

"The report is very clear that no organic lesions are seen, and the defendant's symptoms are very mild." Yuan Dan said.

"We believe that one inspection cannot be concluded, and we apply for a more detailed inspection of the defendant." Chi Weiran said.

"The court has the right to choose which evidence to use. On this issue, there is no need to argue anymore. Does the prosecutor still have evidence to show?" Fang Chaoyang was a little tired of it. Whether the defendant had a mental disorder depends on the process of the case. The appraisal report is not a decisive factor.

"Previous Judge, the prosecutor applies for witnesses to appear in court." Yuan Dan said.

"Whether the witness is allowed?"

"Lu Jiucai."

"The witness Lu Jiucai came to the court." Fang Chaoyang said.

The bailiff brought a middle-aged man in his forties, who was thin and small, with his eyes constantly looking around, and his expression was very nervous.

"Please sit down and tell me your name, age and occupation." Fang Chaoyang said calmly.

"Lu Jucai, forty-five years old, is from Fuyu Village. He pushed up for three generations and was also farmers."

"Witness Lu Jiucai, according to the laws of our country, witnesses have the obligation to testify truthfully to the court. If they intend to perjury, they must bear legal responsibility. Have you heard it clearly?"

"I heard it clearly."

After completing the signing process, Yuan Dan began to ask: "Witness Lu Jucai, on the evening of June 25th twenty years ago, did you see the defendant Shang Zaijun?"

"I saw it, it's really true." Lu Jucai said.

"What are you doing? What are Shang Zaijun doing?" Yuan Dan asked.

"My family is separated from Shang Zaijun's mother's house. I had a stomachache that night. When I was going to the toilet, I saw Shang Zaijun walking out of his mother's house. His waist was bulging, as if something was hidden." Lu Jucai said.

"Protest, he framed me." Shang Zaijun said.

"I didn't frame you. When you came in the morning, I saw you. Wearing rubber shoes and Zhongshan suits, you were still fetching water in the yard." Lu Jucai said.

"I didn't go. You have any problems with your eyes and you are lying." Shang Zaijun said with his neck in his mouth.

"I can swear to my ancestors, I didn't lie, I saw it if I saw it!" Lu Jucai also became stubborn and pointed his hand into the air.

"Quiet!" Fang Chaoyang said coldly, and said, "The prosecution continues to inquire."

"Witness Lu Jucai, do you remember when you saw Shang Zaijun coming out of his mother's house at that time?" Yuan Dan asked again.

"Seven o'clock!"

"Why are you so sure?"

"At that time, my daughter was just over the moon, like an alarm clock, and she had to eat milk every night. At that time, I happened to go to the toilet." Lu Jucai said.

The appearance of key witnesses was the result of the continuous efforts of the police. They visited from house to house and finally found the witnesses of Shang Zaijun in Fuyu Village that night.

"Previous Judge, the prosecutor has completed the inquiry." Yuan Dan said.
Chapter completed!
Prev Index    Favorite Next