Chapter 392 'Nature' must be rejected! (2 updates)
The first choice for academic journals is foreign ones, such as "Nature" in the UK or "Cell" in the United States, which are academic journals with widespread global influence.
It’s not that Wu Yong or Xia Guo Sciences are belittling themselves and are unwilling to submit relevant papers to domestic journals.
But the reality is right in front of us. In terms of biomedical technology, Xia Guo is only a middle-class player in the world.
Most of the advanced science and technology are also mastered abroad.
At the same time, there are no world-class influential academic journals in Xia.
Publishing relevant papers in journals such as Nature or Cell is not unpatriotic, but is to give Chen Xiao's research results a wider influence.
After repeated weighing and deliberation, Wu Yong's team decided to submit this paper to Nature.
There are two reasons for this decision. The first one is that compared with "Nature" and "Cell", "Nature" is a comprehensive academic journal, while "Cell" is a single type academic journal, so Nature's global influence
It is more extensive, and among them, "Nature Clinical Medicine", a subsidiary of "Nature", has no worse influence in the industry than "Cell".
Another reason is that the Xia Academy of Sciences and "Nature" have very good cooperation channels. When the Xia Academy of Sciences has relatively good scientific research results, it will submit relevant papers to "Nature" through this friendly channel.
"Nature" will also undergo strict review, and only papers that meet the requirements will be published. However, this good channel between the two parties can speed up the review of papers.
This kind of cooperative relationship is very necessary in the academic world. If an unknown ordinary scientific researcher sends his research results to "Nature", "Nature" may not invest too much energy in this paper, but
If this paper is sent to "Nature" in the name of the Xia Academy of Sciences, then the level of attention will be much higher.
Wu Yong submitted the paper to the clinical medicine column of "Nature" in the name of Xia Guo Academy of Sciences.
The submitted paper was bilingual in Chinese and English, and the English part was translated by Wu Yong's team with the help of Chen Xiao.
Although this paper was submitted in the name of the Xia Academy of Sciences, the only signature on the paper was Chen Xiao.
British "Nature" magazine headquarters.
"Nature" Clinical Medicine received this paper from the Xia Academy of Sciences.
As usual, the three editors will cross-check the paper and evaluate it.
If the paper has certain scientific research value and meets the conditions for publication in Nature, then the paper will be submitted to the editor-in-chief for review.
The editor-in-chief does not have the final say alone, he will seek the opinions of the academic team.
The reason why "Nature" has become a world-renowned academic journal is that in addition to the extremely high academic level of its editors, there is also an international review expert group behind "Nature". These experts are all from
Well-known professors in related fields around the world and pioneers of cutting-edge academics.
Ferris, editor of Nature Clinical Medicine, was stunned when he saw Chen Xiao's paper.
Some time ago, Ferris saw reports from The Times and BBC about the treatment of lung cancer by Li Dingsheng, the founder of Xia Guo’s aerospace industry.
After reading the entire report, Ferris felt that this was absolutely a fantasy.
The United Kingdom and the United States are the two major powers in the West, and they also lead global development in the medical industry.
The treatment of serious lung diseases was something that neither of these two countries could do, but the Xia people actually managed it?
Currently, the best way to treat lung cancer in the medical community is targeted therapy.
However, the earlier the intervention of targeted therapy must be, the better. If intervention is performed in the late stage of lung cancer, then targeted therapy will be almost ineffective.
In addition, lung transplantation is also a treatment option for lung cancer patients if the cancer cells have not spread.
However, there are currently very few lung transplant cases in the world, and the technology is not very mature. The success rate of lung transplantation is not high, and the 5-year survival rate after transplantation is also very low.
The BBC reported that the Xia Academy of Sciences Medical Center actually removed Li Dingsheng's lungs, and that Li Dingsheng actually appeared at the press conference lively and jumping around.
The most important thing is that the Xia Academy of Sciences said that Li Dingsheng had his lungs removed but did not perform a transplant, which means that Li Dingsheng did not have lungs!
This is definitely a shocking thing, and it is even more unbelievable for Ferris.
At least Ferris felt that this matter was impossible to establish in academia.
Ferris did not expect that the BBC was still reporting such ridiculous news a few days ago, and today the Xia National Academy of Sciences sent the relevant paper.
“How can there be a paper on something this ridiculous?”
Ferris read the contents of the paper in detail.
Whether published papers and experiments are actual papers are different. The published papers only clarify the process and logical relationship of the entire experiment as well as important data.
The paper actually written for archiving the entire experiment contains the detailed process and detailed data of the experiment, which is considered confidential content.
Of course, Chen Xiaofa's published paper is related to it. It only contains the experimental process, and there is no detailed data on the principle and logical relationship, so it will not be classified.
Even so, Ferris was shocked when he saw the paper.
【Influence +20!】
The entire experiment is cleverly designed, with clear logical relationships and rich methods used. The most important thing is that all experimental logic can form a tight closed loop, and all data pre-processing is very clear.
Science does not tolerate any falsehood. If one of your data is fictitious, then all the subsequent data will be wrong. Therefore, Ferris absolutely believes that the data of the entire numerical experiment is real and valid.
"The improved bacterial colonies, through special cultivation methods, are actually able to survive in the human body and produce metabolism. Oxygen can be absorbed by the human body. In this way, humans certainly do not need lungs for breathing and gas exchange."
Ferris wrote down this sentence emphatically in his notebook, and he felt the hairs all over his body stand up.
[Influence +15]
Now Ferris wants to know an answer the most. Did Li Dingsheng's lungs have been removed? If the lungs have really been removed and he is still alive and well, it proves that Chen Xiao's paper is completely true and valid.
.
This absolutely subverts the entire history of human medicine.
Ferris quickly followed the procedure to sign the paper.
This was followed by a cross-review by three editors, all of whom are experts in biomedicine. After seeing the entire process and logical relationships of the paper, as Ferris judged, this paper can definitely change humankind's understanding of the history of medicine.
Ferris' colleague Model said: "It would be great if we could go to Xia Guo to see Li Dingsheng's lung CT in person."
[Influence +10]
[Influence +10]
After cross-review, the paper was placed on the desk of Kelly, editor-in-chief of the Nature Clinical Medicine column.
Kelly is editor-in-chief of Nature Clinical Medicine.
He graduated from the Medical School of the University of Cambridge, and then studied for a doctorate in medicine-related majors at Stanford University. After working in clinical and related laboratories for 5 years, he returned to the UK and became the editor and chief editor of the Natural Clinical Medicine column.
Kelly's profound academic background and rich clinical and experimental experience make Kelly very unique. There have been many papers related to the Nobel Prize in Medicine, which were first discovered by Kelly and published in the magazine "Nature" for the first time.
.
But when he saw the paper submitted by the editors, Kelly felt bad.
Although this paper is completely justified in terms of data and logical relationships, judging from the level of medical and scientific research in Xia State, it is absolutely impossible for Kelly to be able to conduct such an experiment and achieve success.
The West has always been at the forefront of the medical field and has made a lot of efforts in researching lung diseases and has achieved many results.
However, current treatments for major diseases including lung cancer and pulmonary fibrosis are a big problem for the Western medical community.
Humans are aerobic organisms, and the basis for the existence of life is that cells must carry out aerobic respiration.
The lungs are the factories where the human body exchanges gases and are the basis for ensuring that body cells can carry out aerobic respiration smoothly.
How can people survive if there is something wrong with their lungs?
Kelly could never believe that a Xia technology company could solve a problem so quickly that the Western academic community had struggled to solve for decades.
Kelly's first reaction was that Xia Guo's experiment was seriously fraudulent, including the data and logical relationships, which must be false.
How could the people of Xia be able to solve a problem that the West could not solve?
At present, the Xia Kingdom is just a country with very backward science, technology, economy and society.
Kelly looked at some contents of the paper in detail and finally found a weak link in the paper.
According to the description in the paper, the entire experiment actually does not comply with the relevant standards for biomedical experiments.
The most important problem is that the experiment described in the paper did not conduct detailed animal group experiments, and the data and information in the animal group experiments are lacking.
In terms of human experiments, only one case has been conducted on Li Dingsheng. Moreover, Kelly still does not know what the actual situation of Li Dingsheng is.
As a result, the more Kelly thought about the paper, the more illogical it became, and he became more convinced that the paper was a fraud.
Kaili has the same inertial thinking as most people in Western academic circles. How can Xia Guo do something that we can't do?
Kelly still discussed this with the academic committee behind Nature.
When biomedical experts in Europe and the United States saw such a paper, they burst into laughter.
"I'm afraid those people in Xia State are crazy. They skipped animal experiments and conducted clinical trials instead. They also told us that their experiments were successful. I searched all the medical rooms around the world and found this kind of
Trying and researching has never happened before, and it is absolutely impossible to achieve success in a short time."
"Guys and gentlemen, I just came back from giving lectures at Yanjing University in Xia State last year. I have a very good understanding of the current situation of the biomedical community in Xia State. Indeed, they have made great progress in treating diseases, especially epidemic diseases, over the years.
There has been progress, but there is still a big gap between us in top medical science. This paper is obviously fiction."
"We should interview Li Dingsheng and interview that old guy. I suddenly felt that from Xia Guo's report on Li Dingsheng's advanced stage of lung cancer to his miraculous treatment success, it was all a trap, in order to gain Xia Guo's international academic status in the biomedical field."
"This is to save the reputation of Xia Guo's scientific and technological community, which is already very fragile. I have data in my hand. In the past five years, Xia Guo has had a total of 368 academic papers, all of which have been retracted by major academic journals around the world."
“The reason is academic plagiarism of false papers and multiple submissions.”
The experts and scholars of the academic committee were very sure that this paper must be fictional without even looking at the data in detail.
The review results have come out. Kelly threw the paper into the trash can and blocked the name Chen Xiao.
Anyone who submits false papers will definitely be blocked.