After Xie Shuguang finished speaking, two members of the Standing Committee immediately agreed.
Fan Zhiguo glanced at the faces of Executive Vice Governor He Qingrui and Governor Xie Shuguang. A faint smile appeared on the corner of his mouth. He immediately adjusted his original plan and said with a smile:
"Since Xie Shuguang and so many comrades do not want to interfere with Tianhe City's economic development plan, I have no objection. In fact, I convened everyone today to discuss the Tianhe Standing Committee's plan for two purposes. First, I hope that everyone
Through the discussion of this planning plan, we can see the advantages of writing the planning plan separately.
And I can tell you clearly that it only took two weeks for the standing committee members of Tianhe City to write the planning plan. Although it will consume some manpower and material resources, judging from the final results, there are still some parts of these planning plans that belong to them.
The shining point.
My second purpose is to understand the specific governance philosophy and ability of this standing committee member by examining the governance ideas of different standing committee members in Tianhe City.
Because every planning plan is permeated with the efforts of each Municipal Party Committee Standing Committee member, as leaders of the Provincial Party Committee, we can see different people’s different governance philosophies from the planning plans submitted by different Municipal Party Committee Standing Committee members, which provides us with guidance for future selection and appointment.
Cadres provide important reference.
Of course, now that we have all read through all the planning plans, we can now give each planning plan a score.
Let me start from the beginning. I think that among all the planning plans, Comrade Liu Haotian’s planning plan is the most outstanding. I give him 97 points."
Later, Zhou Xilei said with a smile: "I think the score given by Secretary Fan is too conservative. Liu Haotian's planning plan this time can be said to be groundbreaking. Although many governance ideas and governance plans seem a bit radical, it is undeniable.
If these planning plans of Liu Haotian can be implemented well, then the problems of Tianhe City's intensive chemical industry, excess chemical production capacity, and low proportion of high-end product quality will be well solved.
Moreover, from Comrade Liu Haotian's planning plan, I can see an aura of great talent and great strategy.
So, I give it 99 points! The reason why I don’t give it 100 points is because giving it 100 points would seem too perfect, and 99 points is just right.”
Afterwards, everyone else gave their scores.
In the end, the average score of Liu Haotian's planning plan reached 97.8 points!
Even Executive Vice Governor He Qingrui gave it a high score of 95 points.
Although He Qingrui did not agree with the severe compression of the chemical industry mentioned in Liu Haotian's planning plan, he did not dare to express his opinions too fiercely in the face of the approval of so many members of the Standing Committee.
He still gave him a lower score than other members of the Standing Committee to show his true attitude.
Subsequently, the provincial party committee leaders rated the planning plans of other Tianhe Municipal Party Committee Standing Committee members.
The highest score was not Tang Jinquan's planning plan, but Xu Jiajun's planning plan. In the end, Xu Jiajun's planning plan received a high score of 81.2. The third place was actually Chen Yugang, Secretary of the Tianhe Municipal Commission for Discipline Inspection, who received a score of 70.5.
Tang Jinquan’s planning plan ranked fourth, scoring only 68.6 points.
The one with the lowest score was Ma Jinwei, who only got a score of 50.1.
This is thanks to He Qingrui’s high score of 70 points.
Fan Zhiguo only gave 46 points!
Because Fan Zhiguo is very dissatisfied with Ma Jinwei's planning plan. In his opinion, this planning plan can only be regarded as the deputy director level, which is far from the level of executive deputy mayor Ma Jinwei, because he actually started from this level.
Three typos were found in this planning plan, which shows that Ma Jinwei did not pay enough attention to this planning plan.
The only planning plan with a score below 50 points is Ma Jinwei's.
When He Qingrui saw that Fan Zhiguo only gave Ma Jinwei 46 points, a look of dissatisfaction appeared on his face.
After the scoring was over, He Qingrui suddenly said: "Secretary Fan, I have a little doubt, I don't know whether I should say it or not?"
Fan Zhiguo smiled slightly: "We are here at the Standing Committee of the Provincial Party Committee, and any questions can be raised."
He Qingrui nodded: "Although I have no evidence, and although I gave Liu Haotian's planning plan a high score, I think Liu Haotian was able to write such an excellent planning plan in just two weeks, so I have some
I wonder if this planning plan was copied by Liu Haotian from other cities?
Also, I saw that Liu Haotian’s planning plan mentioned a lot of data, and these data are much smaller than the data reported by Tianhe City in the past. So, are the data mentioned by Liu Haotian in the planning plan arbitrary?
Is it fabricated? Could it be deliberately compiled in order to realize some of the views reflected in the planning plan?"
After He Qingrui finished speaking, the conference room immediately fell into silence.
These two views he said really aroused everyone's deep thought.
At this moment, Secretary-General Shangguan Tao said with a smile: "I can answer Vice Governor He's first question."
Everyone looked at Shangguan Tao.
Shangguan Tao said with a smile: "After I got the planning plan from Liu Haotian, and before our meeting officially started, I searched online through different search software based on some key words in the planning plan, and found nothing.
Are there any traces of plagiarism, especially in Liu Haotian’s plan, which proposed many fresh ideas and even gave several very fresh words, all of which are obviously creative.
Therefore, I can basically answer with certainty that Liu Haotian’s planning plan did not plagiarize relevant materials from anywhere.
The most important thing is that there is a certain difference between Liu Haotian's planning plan writing ideas and our administrative system's writing ideas. The main writer of the plan writing is very talented, and the whole plan makes everyone very comfortable to read, rather than using precise words.
But there is no distinctive and normal copywriting.
Liu Haotian's planning scheme has very distinctive personal characteristics, which is impossible to have in any official planning scheme.
According to my speculation, the author of Liu Haotian's planning plan is definitely a literary master. In Liu Haotian's planning plan, the author not only made the entire plan full of literary talent, but also used words accurately, making it impossible to fault anything.
The problems and their level are definitely not comparable to the planning plans circulated by department-level cadres.
In terms of literary talent, the person who wrote this planning plan cannot be compared with Wang Bo who wrote the preface to Prince Teng's Pavilion, but he is not far behind.
I believe this is also the reason why many comrades gave it a high score of more than 90 points."
Many standing committee members present nodded when they heard what Shangguan Tao said, because Liu Haotian's planning plan is very comfortable to read, very easy to understand, but the wording is very precise, which is beyond the ordinary planning plan.
level.
After hearing Shangguan Tao's answer, He Qingrui had a very calm expression on his face. Regarding this possibility, he only raised his own doubts. He also believed that Liu Haotian could not plagiarize.
"So what's the problem with the data? Why are the data cited by Liu Haotian so different from the official data given by Tianhe City?" He Qingrui asked.
Shangguan Tao opened his handbag, took out a thick document from it, handed it directly to He Qingrui, and said with a smile: "Vice Governor He, this document was submitted along with Liu Haotian's planning plan.
The main content of this document is to recalculate and adjust the previous statistical data of Tianhe City. Through a 10-point detailed data review, it directly points out that the real economic development data of Tianhe City in the past five years, especially the Tianhe Chemical Industry Institute
There are huge problems with proportional data.
It can be seen from this audit data adjustment that in the past five years, the real GDP level of Tianhe City has been 30% lower than the data they published! In other words, their water content is as high as 30%.
The chemical industry in Tianhe City accounts for as much as 68% or even 75% of GDP, while the proportion announced by the Tianhe City Statistics Bureau is only a little over 50%. In other words, the data error in the proportion of the chemical industry published by the Tianhe City Statistics Bureau is up to
More than 15%! In other words, they deliberately under-reported the proportion by more than 15%.
Because of this, many of our provincial party committee leaders are not aware of the crisis of the extremely high proportion of chemical industry in Tianhe City.
The reason why I did not produce this document initially was because, firstly, it was not directly related to the planning plan, and secondly, because the real data published in this document could not be directly verified so far.
However, I believe that we only need to find professional auditors to re-audit according to the audit model of this planning plan, and we will be able to get more direct and accurate data.
Therefore, compared to the official data released by the Tianhe Municipal Audit Bureau, I agree more with the actual data used by Comrade Liu Haotian in the planning plan."
After Shangguan Tao finished speaking, the entire conference room suddenly became quiet.
He Qingrui's face looked a little ugly this time.
He didn't expect that his second question would directly stir up a hornet's nest.
If the data determined in the document given by Liu Haotian are true, then it means that the resignation of the director of the Tianhe City Statistics Bureau is an inevitable result, because the falsification of Tianhe City's statistical data is too serious.
Fan Zhiguo still raised his head, and the expression on his face became serious: "I think so, we can directly ask the Provincial Bureau of Statistics, the Audit Bureau and the Provincial Development and Reform Commission, plus the Provincial Commission for Discipline Inspection, the four departments to work together to investigate the matter submitted by Tianhe City
Conduct a comprehensive review of the statistical data to see whether there is a problem with the data provided by Liu Haotian or the data released by Tianhe City in the past five years. Who is responsible and who should be slapped.
Just hit whoever it is! This matter must not be passed off casually."
After Fan Zhiguo finished speaking, He Qingrui was dumbfounded.