"This is a hypothesis made specifically to explain the photoelectric effect. It does not have the universality that a normal theory should have. It cannot be used to explain other phenomena of light. It is even completely contradictory to diffraction images. At the same time, it does not have any accuracy.
Experiments are needed to confirm this theory, which makes one have to doubt that it is always just a hypothesis, a hypothesis that is rigorously deduced, concise and beautiful - but inconsistent with the real situation."
"Arcanists have made many similar hypotheses, but when they are not universal and cannot be used to explain other phenomena, it often means that the hypothesis is in the wrong direction. I have the same feeling about this paper.
view."
"I believe that Mr. Lucien Evans himself has a similar view. He understands the contradiction between this theory and Mr. Brooke's electromagnetic system and many classic optical patterns, so he finally compromised and added a paragraph to clarify that this is just
The processing of instantaneous values, as a whole, takes on the characteristics of a wave.”
The more Roland wrote, the angrier he became. If it weren't for the Lord of Storms, Lucien being a review committee member like himself, and his status forged by honor and arcane skills, he would have imagined Nesika and others scolding Levsky.
He also directly attacked Lucien personally and asked him to wake up, stop being immersed in absurd quantum dreams, and open his eyes to see the stable and complete arcane system.
Taking a deep breath, Roland wrote again: "Furthermore, this hypothesis similar to a variant of particle theory still starts from the perspective of energy discontinuity, which makes people feel ridiculous. Even arcanists who support particle theory will not have any objection to it.
Anyone agrees. Of course, Mr. Lucien Evans fully explained his ideas and gave us a lot of inspiration. At least the photoelectric effect got a
‘Temporarily, the perfect explanation, so my assessment result is:
"For a paper that has a considerable degree of discussion value and is only of discussion value for the time being, you can apply to modify the evaluation results after accurate experimental results are obtained. It is currently recommended to award five arcane points for one arcane point."
In the final summary, Roland wrote very carefully and cunningly, not daring to reveal his tendencies too much. After all, Lucien Evans was not one of those arcanists with no backing or status. If he got caught, he could easily lose his position as a review committee member.
The reason why this paper was approved is that there are still some supporters of particle theory. If we grasp the contradiction between particle theory and Bruker's electromagnetic system and classical optical patterns and directly reject these papers, then the review committee who supports particle theory will
All the papers on the wave theory would be rejected because they were inconsistent with Douglas's light speed experiment and the photoelectric effect. Roland had to compromise to a certain extent and endured his disgust to pass this variant of the particle theory - although the wave theory had already occupied a dominant position, he could
Particle theory still holds on tenaciously and does not admit defeat.
After writing the review results, Roland picked up his pipe and took a sip and then sneered: "Whether you want other arcanists to see this paper or not, I have decided to recommend it to Drummond and let him work on "Arcane"
Published as a semi-discussive article. Lucien Evans, are you ready to accept the criticism and attacks from thousands of arcanists?"
"Since there is currently no other theoretical explanation for the energy quanta hypothesis, not many arcane masters have written papers to refute it, so they can only forget it. But this time it is completely different. You actually dare to go to war directly with one of the two arcane systems.
He is the enemy of most arcanists! There are classic theories and experimental images, but I don’t believe that no one is speaking out!”
After spreading out the paper, writing a letter of recommendation to Drummond and packing it up to send away, Roland stood up, walked around the study room with his hands behind his back, and whispered to himself: "The best way is to use experimental results and images
To refute it, it will be conclusive evidence, leaving Lucien Evans no chance to defend himself, and showing his weakness and powerlessness in front of all arcanists."
In the branch of the Silver Moon Song Alliance in Arlinge, a middle-aged man with a strange appearance is reviewing papers. He has many tattoos in the shape of electric arcs, and the tiny electric currents on his oval bald head make him seem to have grown a head.
She has thick silver-white hair, and her eyes are slightly narrowed, with lightning flashes popping out from time to time.
"Lucien Evans has finally revealed his identity as a supporter of particle theory? Or does he want to use this to promote his quantum theory?" Teixeira, a seventh-level arcanist and eighth-ring magician, said with a smile.
A trace of sarcastic smile, "However, no matter what his purpose is, his paper is worthless except for explaining the photoelectric effect. It must be a result put together purely to explain the photoelectric effect and ignore other theories, hum,
He can only propose it when accurate experiments cannot be carried out, otherwise he will have his head blown off by the experimental images."
"Since he wrote so many words and formulas, let's just admit that the paper has discussion value. Hey, I wonder what that mad dog Alty will think of it?"
Teixeira changed the content of his inner self-talk into written language and wrote it on the paper, and finally wrote: "... It is undeniable that it has certain discussion value and provides us with the direction and direction to explain the photoelectric effect.
Inspiration, it is recommended to reward two arcane points and six arcane points."
He used to have no prejudice against ■, but now he is full of disgust because he attacks the electromagnetic system that is the basis of his own cognition from the angle of particle theory and quantum hypothesis.
If it weren't for Lucien's many achievements and rapid improvement in magic power, he would have doubted whether Lucien's true arcane level was as terrifying as the rumors.
Putting down his quill, Teixeira looked at the information on the photoelectric effect. This was a phenomenon that had been bothering him recently. As he looked at it, he couldn't help but frowned: "If we substitute the hypothesis of Lucien = Evans, the photoelectric effect
It seems that there is really a reasonable explanation, and it is quite consistent with the pursuit of simple, intuitive and beautiful arcane results."
"Why is this happening? A hypothesis that is completely inconsistent with the classical image can explain the photoelectric effect that contradicts the wave theory?"
Alti, who did not want to see Brooke and his students, and whose supporters were arrogant, settled in his hometown town. The black spire was the most eye-catching building in the whole town, and everyone who came and went was filled with awe.
In the study room of the Magic Tower, the expression on Artie's face has changed from anger and disgust to appreciation and ecstasy:
"Haha, light quantum, light quantum, don't think I won't recognize you if you use another word to describe it! How is this different from the photon that particle theory is looking for? One by one, there is a minimum limit, isn't it just a particle?"
"Isn't quantized processing of light another elaboration of particle theory? And after introducing the hypothesis that frequency is related to the energy of a single photon, the photoelectric effect is perfectly explained. Haha, Lucien = Evans is worthy of being the arcana of this generation.
The most outstanding genius in the division, the one with the greatest hope of becoming a Grand Arcanist in the future!"
Lucien's previous proposal for an artificial planet had helped Douglas lay his own theoretical foundation, and this time the light quantum hypothesis clearly stood from the perspective of particle theory, so Alty began to recruit him as a confidant.
"I want to see what those idiots who support the wave theory use to overturn this explanation? Are their classic theories and images useful in the photoelectric effect?"
Arti was in high spirits, gritting his teeth while smiling broadly: "Except for the last paragraph which seems weak, this is the theoretical explanation that best fits my reward at the moment. Well, publish it. If there is no other explanation within a year,
Fifty thousand arcane points will go to Lucien Evans! I really want to give it to him now!"
After sorting out the paper rubbings and sending them to Drummond, Arti thought happily: "From the perspective of particle theory, Lucien's previous energy quanta hypothesis does not seem so difficult to accept. I was convinced at that time.
Past experience has blinded my eyes..."
From the Magician Management Department, Eric received the evaluation results of Lucien's paper.
Having witnessed Lucien's subversive or innovative achievements many times, he flipped through the documents curiously and his face turned livid. He was also a staunch supporter of the wave theory.
After reading the paper and the descriptions of the two committee members, Eric wanted to write something to refute Lucien's light quantum hypothesis, but suddenly, he thought of the periodic table of elements. That time,
Lucien's paper seemed to have received a very low evaluation, but later it was confirmed by his accurate prediction of the discovery of new elements, which made the two committee members admit their mistakes and gave it a very high evaluation again.
"This paper also contains many assumptions based on light quanta... Could it be..." Past experiences planted seeds of doubt in Eric's mind, "It's better to wait for accurate experiments to come out before discussing this issue."
Bar……"
Under Roland's intentional disclosure, although there were still two or three weeks before the release of the next issue of "Arcana", Lucien's proposal of the light quantum hypothesis to explain the photoelectric effect from the perspective of particle theory quickly spread.
, many arcanists cursed after reading this paper, but most of them were like Eric. Due to Lucien's past glory and correctness, they did not dare to directly write a paper to refute, for fear of being thrown out by him.
The results of the experiment are so shocking that my head may explode under a huge impact.
Because of this, after they discovered that this hypothesis could indeed explain the photoelectric effect, they gradually wavered and prepared to wait and see for a while, only discussing and criticizing in private.
Such an atmosphere permeated Arlinge, making Lazar, Annick and others feel indifferent and excluded. However, Lucien seemed not to notice and continued to improve the meditation method and the six-ring magic without any care.
structure.
However, there are always radicals in any group. Towards the end of the month, Lucien received a large number of letters, all of which were anonymous insults, threats and attacks.
After flipping through the pages with a smile, Lucien, who felt like he had become the public enemy of Arlinge, suddenly frowned because one of the letters was too extreme:
"......Maybe I can't kill you, but don't you think about your friends and students? Take back your ridiculous light quantum hypothesis! Admit your mistake to all arcanists!"