Lou Zhiping came up and was rude and aggressive. Although what he said were clichés attacking Chinese medicine, they were also the most difficult to answer.
After all, the theories advocated by traditional Chinese medicine, whether it is yin and yang, meridians, meridians, or qi, cannot be vividly presented in front of people, and it is difficult to be directly convincing.
In order to make today's event more influential, Lou Zhiping hired many media reporters and has surrounded the entire debate stage. The momentum is not inferior to yesterday's World Medical Association inspection.
At this time, everyone focused their eyes on Qin Haodong's face, looking forward to his answer.
Qin Haodong looked at Lou Zhiping with a smile and asked calmly: "Mr. Lou, I heard that you are a well-known scholar and have profound attainments in scientific research?"
"Of course, I have always advocated science."
Lou Zhiping raised his chin as he spoke, with a proud look on his face.
Qin Haodong said: "Then let me ask a question, what is the temperature of the sun? What is its distance from the earth?"
Lou Zhiping, who originally had a professor's degree and always regarded himself as a scientific person, immediately replied: "The surface temperature of the sun is 5,500 degrees Celsius, the core temperature is about 20 million degrees Celsius, and the distance from the earth is 149.6 million kilometers."
After he finished speaking, he felt proud again. Not just anyone could clearly remember these data in their mind.
Qin Haodong smiled and asked: "Professor Lou, did you measure these data? Or did you see it with your own eyes?"
"Well……"
Lou Zhiping almost choked to death on his own saliva, "What nonsense are you talking about? These scientific data are all speculated by scientists!"
If he were asked to measure the temperature of the sun, would he still be alive to this day?
"It's inferred? You say something about traditional Chinese medicine is unscientific without seeing it. Why do you believe this inferred thing?"
"I……"
Lou Zhiping was speechless, licked his dry lips and said, "Mr. Qin, these things are too far away from us and cannot explain anything."
"It's too far away. Let me ask another question, have you met your great-great-grandfather?"
"Never seen it!"
Qin Haodong said: "Then you haven't even seen his face, should you question his existence? According to your theory, only what you see is real and scientific."
"I……"
Only then did Lou Zhiping realize that Qin Haodong was much more difficult to deal with than he thought. He looked happy, but he was getting into trouble every step of the way.
"Qin Haodong, you are totally quibbling!"
"Am I quibbling or are you speaking out of conscience?"
Qin Haodong said: "So things that people have never seen do not mean that they do not exist. For example, genetic codes and viruses are things that we ordinary people have never seen. Do you just say that they do not exist?
Traditional Chinese medicine has existed in China for 5,000 years and has made immortal contributions to the survival and reproduction of the Chinese nation. It is a treasure left to us by our ancestors and no one is allowed to question it!"
The debate he just made may seem a bit tricky and absurd, but the effect is the most direct, most powerful, and easiest for people to accept.
After saying these last words, the audience immediately burst into thunderous applause!
After many debates, Lou Zhiping, although Qin Haodong took the lead, did not panic. After the applause faded, he said: "I often hear you Chinese medicine practitioners use thousands of years of inheritance as weights to prove that this illusory thing of Chinese medicine
, Judging from the facts, it is still unclear whether traditional Chinese medicine has made any contribution since human beings have multiplied to this day.
In the era when we fully believed in traditional Chinese medicine, the average life span of Chinese people was only thirty or forty years old. But since Western medicine entered China, the average life span has now reached more than seventy years. From this point of view, how much do you think traditional Chinese medicine has played? contribution?
I even think that the short lifespan of Chinese people in the past was inseparable from the use of unscientific things like traditional Chinese medicine."
The audience sitting in the audience were all students from the College of Traditional Chinese Medicine. When they heard that Lou Zhiping was confusing right and wrong and slandering Chinese medicine, they immediately became excited and wanted to rush to the stage to debate with this guy.
Qin Haodong still looked calm. He was not irritated by Lou Zhiping's words, nor was his rhythm disrupted by his nonsense. He continued to talk eloquently: "Mr. Lou, according to your theory, when we believed in traditional Chinese medicine, Chinese people have a short life span, but European and American people who have always believed in Western medicine should have a longer life span.
But in fact this is not the case. In the same period of history, the average life span of Europeans and Americans was not as good as that of Chinese people. This can truly illustrate the value of traditional Chinese medicine."
"Okay... Teacher Qin is right, the role of traditional Chinese medicine in China cannot be ignored..."
"Teacher Qin, what you said is great, I support you..."
As soon as Qin Haodong paused, the audience burst into warm applause again.
After waiting for a while, he continued: "Nowadays, people's life span is extended. This is caused by many factors. In ancient times, the average life span of Chinese people was short. The main reason was death from hunger, war and other factors.
From ancient times to the present, when it comes to truly considering medical skills, Chinese medicine has never been inferior. This historical data can fully prove this.
In the process of human development, the Black Death in Europe killed nearly 100 million people, but our China remained unscathed. The Spanish Flu killed nearly 75 million people, but our China was fine. The Justinian Plague in the West killed 25 million people, but our China remained intact. Not affected.
The top ten major infectious diseases with the highest number of fatalities in the world have never broken out in China. What do you think this is based on? Is it luck? Of course not, it is based on our amazing traditional Chinese medicine.
Traditional Chinese medicine has protected the reproduction of our Chinese nation for thousands of years, and now you are questioning it as pseudoscience. Don't you feel ashamed?"
After Qin Haodong finished speaking, there was another burst of cheers and shouts. His words ignited the passion and recognition of traditional Chinese medicine among the students in the audience.
Although Lou Zhiping looked calm, there was a look of panic in his eyes. The young man in front of him did not look like the old Chinese medicine doctor he had dealt with before.
Although those old Chinese medicine doctors have very high medical skills, they have been working in medicine all their lives and are not very flexible in mind, let alone good at speaking.
Just a few months ago, he had a debate with a well-known old Chinese medicine doctor. At that time, he only used a few words to arouse the old Chinese medicine doctor's anger. He completely lost his temper and used the approval of a certain leader to gain me. He received a certain honor to prove the scientific nature of traditional Chinese medicine, which ultimately made him laugh and made him really popular.
The Qin Haodong in front of him was not only young, but also agile-minded and sharp-tongued. His little tricks didn't work at all. He had firmly gained the upper hand since the debate began.
No matter what, today's debate must be a victory. Taking a deep breath and suppressing his panic, Zhiping continued: "Dr. Qin, I have to say that your eloquence is good and you are very good at inciting everyone's emotions, but the fact is The fact is not something you can change with a few beautiful words."
He reached out and took out a newspaper from his pocket: "Dr. Qin, I don't know if you have seen the news three days ago. A Chinese medicine doctor caused the death of a 5-year-old child due to careless use of medicine. I don't know how to face this fact.
, what else can you argue with?"
After he said this, there was silence. This news has indeed become very popular recently, and many people have come out to accuse traditional Chinese medicine because of this matter.
The eyes at the scene focused on Qin Haodong's face again, wondering how this witty teacher Qin would answer.
Qin Haodong said: "Mr. Lou, there is no need to read the newspaper. I have also read about the medical accident you mentioned on the Internet."
Lou Zhiping slammed the table and shouted with great momentum: "A Chinese medicine doctor treated a 5-year-old child to death. It can be said to be unreasonable. What else can you say?"
This fully proves that Chinese medicine is a deceptive trick and cannot cure diseases at all. On the contrary, it is harmful to people!"
Qin Haodong said: "The official result of this medical accident has not yet been given. There is no clear statement whether the death was due to other reasons or due to treatment by traditional Chinese medicine. Please do not make a final conclusion.
Putting aside this medical accident, I would like to ask Mr. Lou, have you done any research on how many deaths are caused by medical accidents caused by traditional Chinese medicine? What is the rate? How many deaths are caused by Western medicine? What is the rate?
"
"This...I don't know."
Lou Zhiping did not answer. In fact, he had done this kind of research and originally wanted to use it as an important weight to attack traditional Chinese medicine. However, after the results came out, he found that both the number of deaths and the probability of death caused by traditional Chinese medicine were far lower than those of Western medicine.
"Mr. Lou is a well-known scholar, so he doesn't know these data or dare not show them?" Qin Haodong sneered, "Realistically speaking, the number and proportion of deaths caused by Western medicine are much higher than those caused by traditional Chinese medicine.
To be more specific, how many people die every year due to penicillin allergy? How many people die because of incorrect diagnosis? How many people die because of improper surgery?
When Western medicine cures people, why don’t you say it’s witchcraft and unscientific?”
"I……"
Lou Zhiping was speechless again and used the case as a physical attack. This was also one of his common methods, but it failed again in front of this young man.
Qin Haodong turned to the reporters and students around him and said: "Whether it is Western medicine or traditional Chinese medicine, it is inevitable that there will be cases of failure, but once there are cases of failure, the results will be completely different.
Western medicine's failure to treat people's death is a normal case and is inevitable. It will not affect its scientific nature or its status in reality, and no one will stand up and criticize it.
But when it comes to Chinese medicine, once a medical accident occurs, many people will jump in and scold them, saying that Chinese medicine is witchcraft, a lie, and unscientific."
This time there was no applause in the audience. Instead, everyone fell into silence. The atmosphere became extremely heavy. These words caused everyone to think deeply.
This is indeed the case. When medical errors occur in Western medicine, many people subconsciously believe that this is inevitable or even natural.
But when this happens to traditional Chinese medicine, the whole society loses tolerance and starts to criticize and curse. What exactly caused this situation to happen?
Lou Zhiping shouted again: "Qin Haodong, I admit that you are very quibbling, but these things you said are all nonsense.
The yin and yang and meridians mentioned by traditional Chinese medicine cannot be seen, and what you mentioned is still invisible. All you can do is use these imaginary things to deceive the public. These are not scientific at all and cannot be tolerated at all.
The test of time.”
Knowing that this guy was just a dog raised in the West, doing things with money, and having no so-called scientific spirit at all, Qin Haodong also lost interest in continuing to argue with him, and said with a sneer: "You mean something that cannot be seen
Is it just unscientific?”
Lou Zhiping shouted almost hysterically: Of course, Chinese medicine is inherently illusory. It was made up by you people to deceive people. It is the most unscientific model!"