At this time, everyone had clearly seen that the young man speaking was Qin Fen.
The young man who had originally sworn his vows suddenly felt his heart skip a beat when he saw Qin Fen appear, and said hurriedly: "Vice President Qin, I'm just discussing the matter. Although this chicken cup is exactly the same as the one in Nanhe Province, but look carefully.
Look, there are still some differences, so I dare to say that this chicken bowl cup from Dongchang is not a Chenghua doucai, but looks more like a replica from the Republic of China."
"Oh, it turns out to be President Jiao Wen of Nanhe Province. There seems to be nothing wrong with what you say. After all, we value a hundred schools of thought contending and a hundred flowers blooming. But your arbitrary remarks are indeed somewhat inappropriate. Since they are different, how can you
Don’t you think your chicken cup from Nan Hoa Province is an imitation?!”
Qin Fen chuckled and asked directly.
"This...I...I, Jiao Wen, have been studying porcelain for many years, so I can conclude that this chicken bowl cup in Dongchang is not from the Chenghua period of the Ming Dynasty!"
Jiao Wen hesitated for a long time and finally managed to choke out a few words.
"Haha, okay, let's take a look at everyone's opinions!" After Qin Fen finished speaking, he turned his gaze on the people gathered around him and said, "You are all the leaders in the cultural industry in each province. Take a look, these two
Of the chicken cups, which one is the real thing?!"
As soon as Qin Fen finished speaking, these people all came forward, took out the magnifying glasses and other treasure appraisal items in their bags, and began to observe the chicken bowl cup in the Dongchang display cabinet.
To be honest, these people have not done much research on the Chenghua Doucai Chicken Cup, because it is much rarer than Yuan blue and white, because there are only a dozen pieces in existence today, and whether these dozen pieces are really all from Chenghua
This is still open to debate, but one thing is that the more than ten surviving pieces are now scattered in museums around the world.
Moreover, these more than ten pieces of fighting colors will be more or less different.
After viewing the Dongchang booth, these people walked towards the Nan Hoa booth again.
Qin Fen stood aside with Xu Hongming and others. Seeing the smile on Qin Fen's face, Xu Hongming and Tao Boru's expressions became a little solemn.
"Qin Fen, this time the comrades from the cultural relics bureau and some experts from our association have appraised these cultural relics from various provinces. To be honest, the appearance of the chicken vat cup from Dongchang and the chicken vat cup from Nanhe is very different.
The sizes are basically the same, but there are some differences in the doucai."
"I know that even if it is fired in one kiln, there will be some difference!" Qin Fen nodded and said.
"Qin Fen, President Xu didn't mean that. He meant..."
At this time, Tao Boru saw Qin Fen's indifferent look and hurriedly whispered, but when the words came to his lips, he did not say them out.
Seeing Tao Boru's hesitant look, Qin Fen frowned, knowing that these two people must be hiding something from him, and immediately said doubtfully: "If you two have anything to say, just say it. Seeing you like this makes me confused!
"
Xu Hongming and Tao Boru looked at each other, and finally Tao Boru said again: "Actually, our expert team has been identifying these two chicken pot cups for a long time, and it has been difficult to unify their opinions, but the final conclusion is..."
Seeing that Tao Boru was stuck again, Qin Fen basically guessed what the other person was thinking, and immediately said: "The appraisal result is that the Chenghua chicken cup from Dongchang is a replica, right?!"
The two of them were stunned at the same time, but in the end they nodded helplessly. The reason why they didn't tell Qin Fen was because they were worried that Qin Fen would not be able to bear it. Unfortunately, they still underestimated Qin Fen, not to mention Qin Fen's mental ability to bear it.
Well, let’s talk about Qin Fen’s incredible treasure-appraisal skills. Of course he knows which one is real and which one is fake.
"Haha, don't be like this, you two. There are only a dozen or so Chenghua Chicken Cups in existence, and they are still scattered all over the world. Moreover, the ones that exist are all suspect at best. Which one is genuine and which one is genuine?
Later generations of imitations are widely criticized, but in the end, the facts must speak for themselves!”
Seeing Qin Fen being so optimistic, Xu Hongming and Xu Hongming were stunned again, and then asked seriously: "Qin Fen, are you sure that this chicken bowl cup from Dongchang is genuine?!"
"hehe……"
Qin Fen chuckled at the two of them, and then set his sights on the booth of Nanhe Province not far away. At this time, the experts who came forward to appraise the products began to discuss in low voices.
"Let's listen to everyone's opinions!"
At this time, Qin Fen turned around and spoke to Xu Hongming and Tao Boru again, and then slowly walked towards the crowd.
"Everyone, are the identification results out yet?!" Qin Fen asked everyone.
After hearing Qin Fen's question, these people all stopped talking and looked up at Qin Fen. However, the expressions of these people were very complicated, as if it was difficult to make a conclusion for a while.
"Well, since you won't tell me, let me tell you first. In fact, I have been studying porcelain for decades. Anyway, I have some experience. I just took a closer look at these two chicken cups. I
My heart prefers this chicken vat cup from Nanhe Province!"
"Well, I also think that Nanhe Province only dates from the Chenghua period of the Ming Dynasty!"
"I think the one in Dongchang is more like one from the Chenghua period!"
As expected, the opinions of these people are also very divided, and it seems that the majority support Nan Hoa Province.
For a time, everyone fell into a stalemate, and everyone was talking about the basis for their own identification.
"Vice President Qin, I have long heard that you have a superb level of treasure appraisal. You might as well tell me which of these two chicken jar cups is the real one?!"
At this time, someone finally couldn't stand it any longer.
Sure enough, everyone's eyes were on Qin Fen, hoping they would give their opinions.
Qin Fen glanced at the crowd indifferently, and then said with a smile: "Before I perform the appraisal, I must first make it clear to everyone that my identity at this moment is just a vice president of the National Cultural Heritage Association, so I will never be biased.
Either way, I guarantee this with my personality!”
As soon as these words came out, many people's expressions changed. After all, many people were wondering whether Qin Fen would favor Dongchang, but they blocked their mouths first and used their character as a guarantee, so there was no need to worry.
, being involved in the antique business, personality is particularly important.
"Vice President Qin, we believe in you!"
"That's right, we believe you!"
Hearing the approval of many people, Qin Fen nodded slightly to everyone, and then turned his eyes on Jiao Wen, "President Jiao, I don't know what you are thinking?!"
"I, Jiao Wen, am not a villain. Vice President Qin has said so, so I must believe you." Jiao Wen showed a hint of displeasure on his face and said coldly.
"Haha, okay, then let me tell you my opinion. The two chicken bowl cups look the same in appearance, and they are both ancient objects. But according to my appraisal, I conclude that the Dongchang chicken bowl cup is Chenghua
The colorful chicken cup, and the one from Nanhe Province should be an imitation from the Yongzheng period of the Qing Dynasty!"
"Wow..."
As soon as he said this, everyone in the house was shocked. These people were somewhat surprised. They didn't expect Qin Fen's appraisal to be so decisive, without any hesitation of speculation.
"Vice President Qin, what is your basis?!"
At this time, someone could not wait to ask questions.
As for Xu Hongming and Tao Boru, they were even more surprised. They thought that Qin Fen really wanted to favor Dongchang, right? After all, most of the appraisal results showed that Dongchang's is a replica! Now that Qin Fen is so sure, what's the point?
What is it based on?!
Everyone's eyes were on Qin Fen, and he only saw a smile on his face, and then said again: "Those who know porcelain must know Ming Chenghua's fighting color. There is no difference in the shape and size of these two chicken cups.
They are both at the level of beauties. The difference lies in the fighting color."
"Doucai?!"
"Yes, we are all experts, so I won't go into details. The main technique of this Dou Cai is actually to outline the outlines of some flowers and birds on the white porcelain, then fire it at high temperature, then fill it with various required colors, and finally
Then it was fired in the kiln. This technique was at its peak only in the Ming Dynasty, and imitations in later generations became increasingly sloppy."
Qin Fen nodded and said directly.
"That's true, but the two pieces of doucai seem to have their own merits, and the chicken cup from Nanhe Province looks more elegant than the one from Dongchang in terms of texture, glaze and blue and white.
It stands out!”
At this time, someone raised doubts again.
"What we are identifying now is which one is Chenghua Doucai, not which one is more gorgeous. If we want to say it is more gorgeous, then the modern imitation must be more outstanding, right?!"
When Qin Fen asked this question, the man immediately blushed and did not dare to say anything else.
"Vice President Qin, I'm afraid it's hard to convince the public just by relying on this. And I think you don't know something. Now we have a Chenghua Doucai Chicken Cup in the Beijing Museum, and that Chicken Cup is similar to
The one we have in Nanhe Province is obviously exactly the same, so your statement is somewhat far-fetched."
At this time, Jiao Wen curled up the corner of his mouth and walked directly towards Qin Fenleng.
This statement attracted many people's nods, and it was obvious that their basis was because they had seen the Chenghua Doucai Chicken Cup in the Beijing Museum, so they dared to be so sure.
"Qin Fen, President Jiao Wen is right. There is indeed a Chenghua Doucai Chicken Cup in the Beijing Museum. Most experts identified it based on this!"
At this time, Tao Boru hurriedly spoke to Qin Fen. It seemed like he was telling Qin Fen, but in fact he was reminding Qin Fen.
Qin Fen nodded happily towards Tao Boru and said, "Although I have never seen the chicken jar cup in the Beijing Museum with my own eyes, after hearing what you said, I have basically concluded that you must have entered a misunderstanding!"
"What misunderstanding?!" someone asked directly.
"Haha, do you think the chicken cup in the Beijing Museum is really the Chenghua Doucai chicken cup?!"
Qin Fen asked the same question.
This immediately attracted everyone's doubtful glances. What did Qin Fen mean by this?! Wasn't this clearly questioning whether the one in the Beijing Museum was a replica?!
Their guess was correct. Although Qin Fen had never seen the chicken bowl cup in the Capital Museum, if it was really like what these people said, then the cup in the Capital Museum was probably not from this dynasty, but a later imitation!