Chapter 1364 The words are not surprising and swear endlessly!
In class.
Miao Liyun's voice echoed, making many people tremble in their hearts.
Just by hearing the name, you can tell how cruel the human sacrifice system is. It is precisely because of this that historians have mixed reviews of Ming Taizu.
Even Zhang Jieyun frowned slightly at this time and didn't know how to refute for a while.
The scene became quiet.
"Okay, thank you two classmates for giving us a wonderful debate."
Fan Xueqin laughed loudly, breaking the silence of the scene.
"In general."
"Actually, neither of them was wrong, but in fact they were both wrong."
Wow.
There was an uproar in the classroom.
Including Miao Liyun, Zhang Jieyun, and other students, they all looked over in confusion.
What does it mean to say nothing wrong but say everything wrong at the same time?
Some students couldn't help but ask: "Teacher, we all don't understand."
"First point, I have said before that whether you are looking at a dynasty or a king, you should never take a look at the situation. Instead, you should look at the entire social situation and bring your mind into that era and that environment."
"First, let's explain Taizu's merits."
"Is this just his fault?
Not sure, maybe the subjective condition is his, but the objective condition is that in the late Yuan Dynasty, social turmoil was violent and the people were in dire straits, so there were so many uprisings and resistance."
"Just like me, I asked you all to give me extra hours today, and you are not allowed to eat or go to the toilet. Are you happy?
I guess some classmates will quietly call the Education Bureau to report me."
Fan Xueqin made a funny analogy.
Suddenly, the class burst into laughter, and the previous dullness completely dissipated.
"Let's continue talking."
"In addition to the riots, the most important thing for Emperor Taizu of the Ming Dynasty was the environment at that time. Life was unbearable. He could only stand up and resist with the strong men from the sky, so that he could have rice and meat."
"Moreover, we relied on many powerful generals and counselors to eliminate the rebellion and bring peace to the world, including the subsequent establishment of the Ming Dynasty and various measures to stabilize the country."
"These contributions can be largely attributed to Ming Taizu, but other ordinary people must not be forgotten."
Fan Xueqin talked eloquently.
Even after he said this, everyone started to think a little.
indeed.
Regardless of historical records or various judgments, they all overly demonize ancient emperors.
But in fact, the rise and fall of a dynasty cannot be completely controlled by one person. It is like playing the beacon fire drama on the princes. Many people blame Baosi for the destruction of the dynasty because they have read the most famous fable, but they have forgotten it.
The dandyism of King You of the Zhou Dynasty, and the conflicts in the last years of the Western Zhou Dynasty.
No matter how good a king is, no matter how powerful his methods of governing the country are, without killing soldiers, planning counselors, and capable officials, a huge dynasty cannot be sustained.
"Teacher, if the credit is not entirely due to Ming Taizu, then where is the fault?"
Miao Liyun couldn't help but ask.
"Mistake..." Fan Xueqin said lightly: "A dynasty has just been established. It is the most powerful time, but it is also the weakest time."
"I told you last time that many dynasties that lasted only a few years were because after the king came to the throne, he forgot about everything and got carried away, and was quickly abolished."
"As Emperor Taizong of the Tang Dynasty said, water can carry a boat but also capsize it. If Taizu of the Ming Dynasty really massacred heroes for no reason, do you really think that no one would dare to resist?"
Fan Xueqin's tone was low and he said slowly: "Countless historians want to find out the reason why Ming Taizu established party prisons in his later years."
"It seems that it was not just because of the rebellion. It seems that those registered were not implicated in the massacre. There is even evidence that all this was a cover-up of Ming Taizu..." As soon as these words came out.
Everyone was suddenly shocked.
But only Tang Ming, there was a sparkle in his eyes at this moment! His hands suddenly clenched tightly.
Then stood up straight away.
Tang Ming said in a deep voice: "Teacher, I have a question that I would like to ask for advice."
"You said that as long as the teacher knows, he will definitely answer your questions."
Fan Xueqin smiled.
Regardless of the fact that he is the head of the Fan family, which is also a well-established wealthy family, in fact, because of Fan Zhongtian, the Fan family has a very special status and has never participated in the struggles between various forces in Jinling.
In addition, Fan Xueqin himself is also a literary and intellectual fanatic, so he does not know Tang Ming's true identity.
"Teacher, according to what you said before, can I understand that... those heroes and soldiers who were registered and recorded as being implicated in the massacre were not actually massacred, but Ming Taizu deliberately confused the public and allowed these heroes to carry out the execution?
Secret mission?”
Tang Ming didn't hesitate and went straight to the point and dropped a bombshell.
Boom! These words shocked everyone.
Tang Ming's words were really shocking and sounded like nonsense. But if you think about it carefully and combine it with what Fan Xueqin said, it makes people's thoughts spin.
at this time.
Even Fan Xueqin couldn't help but frown and subconsciously pushed his glasses. People who are familiar with him know that this is a subconscious action when his thoughts are running rapidly.
The place became quiet again.
One minute, two minutes, five minutes... ten minutes passed.
Fan Xueqin slowly raised his head: "This student, although your statement is a bit strange, it is not nonsense after thinking about it carefully."
"In his later years, Emperor Taizu of the Ming Dynasty established a large number of party prisons. He only believed in the Jin Yiwei and instituted various torture methods. It stands to reason that so many people died, and the court must be full of turmoil."
"On the contrary, there was no turmoil."
"This is also the point of confusion for countless historians. It is really unreasonable."
Fan Xueqin looked at Tang Ming, hesitated for a moment and then said: "Classmate, since you asked this, do you also have your own guess?"
"The Ming Dynasty has strong soldiers and horses. What mission is worthy of Ming Taizu not to hesitate to ruin his reputation for future generations, and even needs to be carried out in such a secretive manner?"
Whoa! Everyone looked over.
For some reason, many students were inexplicably excited at this time.
It was obviously a boring history class, but now it has slowly turned into a suspense class.
"For example, is it related to the mausoleum?"
"Every king, the more talented the king is, will definitely have regrets in his heart. He regrets that his life span is short. Everyone wants to be the one who lives forever and establish the immortal dynasty!"
"Ming Taizu is known as the Great Emperor Hongwu, and the word Hongwu has the same name as the Taoist Hongwu Tianzun. With a mortal body, he can stand shoulder to shoulder with the gods, which implies immortality."
Tang Ming said he would never stop saying it was not surprising.
As soon as you open your mouth.
A muffled thunder fell, causing Fan Xueqin's expression to change drastically.
The scholar's reason told him that the news he heard was too unbelievable. It was not history but a bizarre myth.
It can be thought of the history that I have studied in the past few decades, including all the weird things in Ming Taizu's later years.
For the first time, Fan Xueqin was confused about the history he knew.