Scroll B, Morning Dew Waiting for Sun Xi, Section 22, New Debate Contest!
"Brothers, this is what I think. Based on what we have listed in our current article, I think everyone has their own opinions on these views, especially how such disadvantages are formed and how to deal with them.
Everyone must have their own opinions and opinions when it comes to solutions and improvements, and even one thing or one opinion may lead to exactly the opposite result..."
Feng Ziying talked eloquently and firmly controlled the situation.
"...For example, we all know that the Kaizhong method used in the salt method is extremely important to Xubian, but its disadvantages are also obvious. Do we have to stick to the Kaizhong method, can we improve it, or start from scratch and use more appropriate methods?
solve?"
"..., since every issue may have different views and opinions, and it cannot be denied that even some good strategies have some shortcomings and flaws, then whether the advantages outweigh the disadvantages, or the disadvantages outweigh the advantages, I am afraid that many times
It's a matter of opinion. In this case, I think we can fight through a face-to-face debate..."
This is actually a replica of the modern debate competition, brought to this era.
There are debates in this era, and even many people are not weak in eloquence. It’s just that this method of first picking out a question, and then having both sides temporarily choose a side to debate and confront is very new, and for many people
, since you have determined that a certain direction is correct, you naturally have to defend the other party from this perspective. However, if you get the negative side, I am afraid that he will be speechless. Therefore, if you want to engage in this kind of debate and confrontation, you must
Let them understand this rule.
Sure enough, when Feng Ziying proposed this rule idea, it immediately aroused heated debate.
"Ziying, your idea is really interesting. Since we all agree with this point of view, why do we still debate from the opposite side?" Xu Xie was very interested and asked with a smile: "Like opening up the Chinese law, we all know that this is
It is an important measure to ensure the defense of the nine-border military supply. If the Kai-Zhong Law is lost, the consequences will be disastrous. You want us to say that the Kai-Zhong Law is not good and can even be abolished or replaced. How can you argue with this?"
"Senior Brother Xingzhou, we all know that the Kaizhong method is good, but why has the Kaizhong method been corrupted in just a few decades?" Feng Ziying asked with a leisurely smile: "Do you think the emperor and the elders are not aware of this?"
A little bit? Can’t you see the danger here? No, but why is it still slowly but irreversibly collapsing? I think there must be a reason. So as the opponent, we must find out the reason here and try our best.
Explain all methods to make the arbitration believe that the disadvantages of opening the Chinese method outweigh the advantages... If you can do this, then you will naturally win. Even if you can't do it, the reasons you mentioned are sufficient, and I believe the arbitration will recognize it.
…”
Xu Xie frowned. This junior brother seemed to have been prepared for it. This statement cannot be said to be perfect, but it must have been planned for a long time.
"Ziying, do you think that the problems listed in this article can be explained by various reasons from both positive and negative aspects to clarify the existing problems?" Xu Xie took a deep breath.
"Senior Brother Xingzhou, you have always been known for your rigorous thinking. I think that every institutional rule in the imperial court has its own sufficient reasons, which means that every problem that arises must be caused by something wrong in some aspects. Since it is Analyzing the debate, one side mainly explains the necessity and feasibility of establishing the rules of this system, while the other side explains the reasons and harms of its problems, and then proves that its shortcomings have become so great that they must be changed. Who wins and who loses? It just depends on who can convince the arbitration..."
The students around were all talking in whispers. This proposal was undoubtedly very challenging and confrontational. It was easy to arouse everyone's enthusiasm by giving gongs and drums in front of each other.
You can describe the benefits and advantages of a thing or a system, and he can attack the shortcomings you mentioned. He also needs to explain why his reasons are reasonable and how to implement them. Similarly, you also need to find out what the other party is saying. loopholes in the strategy to counterattack.
In a word, it is the art of contradiction. Use your own spear to pierce the opponent's shield, and at the same time use your own shield to defend your own disadvantages. At least you must have the ability and preparation to defend yourself.
You can either choose to maximize your own strengths, or you can consider how to make up for your shortcomings. But before that, you need to think through both sides of a problem, and consider both the pros and cons.
Because you are not sure whether you will draw heads or tails, it is this uncertainty that brings greater challenges.
This was originally an extremely simple method in a debate in modern society, but it seems particularly novel in this time and space.
The most important thing is that this is a debate on current policy.
This also means that if this kind of debate competition continues to be implemented in the future, the topics that may be involved may be related to current policy theory, and this is exactly the scope of the questions in the Qiu Wei and Spring Wei competitions.
In particular, this kind of current policy theory involving national issues is the focus of Chunwei's exam questions. It's no wonder that the students here in Xiyuan pay so much attention to it.
Even for Xiyuan students, their understanding of current affairs is one-sided and weak. If they can obtain more information about current affairs through some channels, and then brainstorm and form a systematic discussion and discussion mechanism, this will undoubtedly greatly improve their understanding of current affairs. The level of ability of the entire Qingtan Academy to cope with the Autumn and Spring Competitions.
Guan Yingzhen, who was standing behind Bai Shi, moved slightly.
He obviously thinks more and further than these students.
Students may only think about the present moment and themselves, but as the dean, and as the possible successor to the mountain chief in the future, he has to consider the future development of the entire academy.
Feng Ziying's proposal undoubtedly opened an unusual window for Qingtan Academy, allowing students to see more things in the distance outside the window, and to be able to get a head start in understanding, which means opportunities and advantages. .
This can almost lay an unshakable advantage for the future of Qingtan Academy.
Feng Ziying's introduction was very detailed and accurate, allowing the students to easily understand what is involved in such a debate competition and what is at stake.
The students gathered around became a little restless, discussing with each other the strategies and countermeasures of this confrontational debate.
Some people who pride themselves on being articulate have certainly thought of their own advantages, and some people who think they are thoughtful are also aware of their own strengths. How to form a perfect defense team must also consider the concerted efforts of a group.
Xu Xie pursed his thin lips and frowned, then turned his eyes to Lian Guoshi, who was also thinking silently. After a while, he met Xu Xie's eyes and nodded slightly.
Fan Jingwen and He Fengsheng also exchanged looks and finally agreed, accepting this challenge on behalf of Dongyuan.
Although they also felt that they needed to think carefully here, at this juncture, they could not retreat and could only hold on.
A battle between the East and West Gardens was decided in front of the students from both sides, which aroused endless excitement among the students.
Just thinking about it makes me excited. East Park will definitely send the best students, and West Park will definitely not give in to avoid being pulled down by the juniors. They will also send the strongest lineup to fight.
This will be an out-and-out battle between dragons and tigers. The referee will be composed of the mountain chief, the dean and several other professors, and the audience will be the students of Dongxiyuan themselves.
I recommend the beautiful writer Zhou Zhou's "Return to the Ming Dynasty to Be a Foolish King", which describes the end of the Ming Dynasty. If you like this kind of thing, you can read it.