Fan Chunren turned his head and looked at Zhang Fei, "What do you say?"
Zhang Fei said solemnly: "If the ugliest side of Huang Lao Er cannot be exposed, the chances of winning this lawsuit will be much smaller."
This lawsuit is an extra-legal affair, so the affection must be in place, otherwise, it will be difficult for the affection to break through the boundaries of the law.
Fan Chunren pondered for a moment: "The presiding judge must have asked the right questions. Otherwise, there is no need for you to appeal. The judge standing next to you will definitely reject the presiding judge's decision."
"This is different!"
Zhang Fei shook his head.
Fan Chunren asked: "What's the difference?"
Zhang Fei said: "The Erbi is offensive and can set traps in questions, but the presiding judge is asking questions in a fair manner and is not aggressive. He just raises his own questions about doubts. The other party is very
It is easy to guess, and we could have thought of countermeasures in advance, but it is difficult to expose the ugliest side of the other party."
Fan Chunren nodded slightly and asked: "Then which interrogation method do you think is more fair?"
Zhang Fei smiled and said: "Does it need to be said? Of course it is the former."
"Why?" Fan Chunren asked.
Zhang Fei said: "Because both parties will do their best to protect their clients and spare no effort to attack the other party, this is almost certain. If the presiding judge mainly asks questions."
He turned his head to look at Fan Chunren and said with a smile: "Fan Sijian and I have fought two lawsuits. You should know that many questions may seem fair, but if you ask them at different times and change the order, the effect will be
Very different."
Fan Chunren frowned and said nothing.
He was the only one who felt deeply about this.
Because he had fought against Zhang Fei, many issues that were beneficial to him had to be hidden, and he had to wait for the other party to take action first, and then bring it out to refute. If he brought it out first, he might be counterattacked by his opponent.
If it is led by the presiding judge, who knows what he is thinking and what his purpose is in asking this question.
Xu Zhiqian, who was in the hall, also felt that something was wrong. Looking at Liang Dong's attitude, she didn't know how much room they would be given.
In the previous interrogation method, Erbi was also qualified to ask questions, but the main line was controlled by the judge, and Erbi could only plead based on the judge's questions.
as expected.
When Huang Yongli came to the court, Liang Dong directly asked: "Huang Yongli, as an only son, why don't you take your elderly mother to live with you?"
Since the Song Dynasty attached great importance to filial piety, there was a provision in the "Song Xingtong" that if one had different sources of wealth and insufficient support, one could be charged with being unfilial.
That is, children take advantage of their parents' old age to divide their parents' property privately and establish separate families. As a result, the children fail to fulfill their responsibility to support their parents.
This crime carries a maximum penalty of death.
Therefore, no matter how cruel Huang Yongli was, he would not dare to sell the house while his mother was still alive.
Liang Dong had to question this point when he came up.
Huang Yongli immediately called out the injustice: "The officials clearly knew that the villain was wronged. After his father passed away, the villain always wanted to take his mother to live with the villain, but his mother was used to living in the old house and never wanted to live with the villain.
Living together, the villain even had several arguments with his mother over this."
Xu Zhiqian immediately said: "If you are really filial, why have you never shown up during your mother's birthday in recent years?"
Huang Yongli looked sad, shook his head and said: "This is indeed my negligence. These years, I have been focusing on making money to support the family and neglected my mother's birthday. I am really unfilial!"
As he spoke, he choked with sobs and wiped his eyes.
Li Lei on the opposite side immediately said: "About this, Secretary Lu can send someone to inquire about how busy Huang Yongli is every day. He gets up early every day and often forgets his own birthday. Madam Xu has been pampered since she was a child, so she naturally does not understand the common people.
The hard work."
Xu Zhiqian was also forced to change the subject of the inquiry and said to Liang Dong: "If Si Lu knew what Huang Yongli was doing on the eighth day of July two years ago, he would know that what he told was all lies and cannot be trusted."
These questions were originally used to question Huang Yongli, but now she can only directly convince the presiding judge.
Liang Dong asked Huang Yongli: "What were you doing on the eighth day of July two years ago?"
Huang Yongli thought for a while and said with a slight guilt: "It seems to be the villain's thirtieth birthday that day."
Liang Dong immediately looked at Li Lei.
Huang Yongli immediately explained: "That's all the villain's wife has to do, it has nothing to do with the villain!"
Xu Zhiqian asked again: "Did you invite your mother to go that day?"
Huang Yongli replied: "Of course I invited you, but my mother refused to come."
Of course he didn't ask, but that's hard to prove.
Xu Zhiqian said: "My only son's thirtieth birthday, but his mother refused to come. Can Uncle Huang explain why?"
After hearing this, Li Lei's eyes flashed with joy.
Huang Yongli said: "Didn't I say it before? I had argued with my mother several times before, and she was angry with me."
Xu Zhiqian was just about to continue asking, but Liang Dong asked first: "You kindly took your mother to live with you, which can be regarded as a sign of filial piety. Even if your mother doesn't want to, she shouldn't be angry with you. Please tell me honestly.
Is there another hidden secret?"
Xu Zhiqian saw that Liang Dong's question was reasonable, so she remained silent.
Huang Yongli glanced at Liang Dong guiltily and said: "The villain dare not deceive the officials. In fact, the villain wanted to take his mother to live with the villain, and then sold the old house."
"Asshole!"
Liang Dong immediately reprimanded: "In the final analysis, you are not trying to fulfill your filial piety, but you are trying to obtain your parents' property. It is really unreasonable."
Li Lei immediately said: "Si Lu Mingjian, in fact, there is no conflict between the two. Huang Yongli really wants to sell the old house, because for him, this is actually killing two birds with one stone. He can fulfill his filial piety and get a fortune at the same time.
Money can take your business to the next level.”
Liang Dong said: "You are just sophistry. Don't you think you can't fulfill your filial piety if you don't sell this old house?"
Li Lei was speechless.
Huang Yongli also bowed his head in guilt and remained silent.
Liang Dong gave a slap in the face and scolded: "Why don't you hurry up and get the real deal?"
Huang Yongli said: "Little man. The little man wants to take his mother to live at home. It is true that he has some selfish motives, but he also really wants to take his mother to live at home."
Li Lei further explained: "Si Lu, it is human nature to have some disputes between mother and son. Although Huang Yongli acted unfilially, he eventually respected his mother's wishes and did not force his mother to sell the house."
Liang Dong nodded slightly.
Xu Zhiqian was completely dumbfounded. When Liang Dong asked these questions, she didn't even have a chance to interrupt. Her rhythm had been completely disrupted by Liang Dong.
Liang Dong's questions seemed fair, but in fact he followed the other party's answers and asked them instead of raising questions.
It seems that it is very unfavorable to Huang Yongli, but in fact it has been proved from the side that Huang Yongli actually wants to take his mother to live with him. No matter what the reason, at least he has this plan.
Although filial piety is mixed with interests, who can calculate how much filial piety accounts for and how much interests account for.
And he can also use quarreling with his mother to explain many of his unfilial behaviors.
If a mother and son are angry, it is considered unfilial. The son should give up to his mother. This will definitely be criticized by scholars, but for the people in the market, this is also human nature.
It's definitely not a heinous crime.
You can tell something from the attitude of the people watching at the door.
No one acted very angry.
Some people are even thinking that this old woman is really too stubborn. It is not easy for her son to do business. If you live with your son, it will be good for you and your son.
Xu Zhiqian was immediately panicked. The situation was already very unfavorable to her. Liang Dong had already decided whether Huang Yongli had invited his current head of the family. If it could not be reversed, it would be very troublesome.
However, Liang Dongcai
He was the chief judge, and he would not accommodate these Erbis. He just waited for a moment, and when Xu Zhiqian was silent, he said loudly: "Pass the Liu Wu family."
Xu Zhiqian was suddenly startled and said quickly: "Si Lu, I... I haven't finished asking yet?"
Liang Dong smiled and asked: "Do you have any questions?"
Xu Zhiqian had not yet thought of a countermeasure.
Liang Dong said very tolerantly: "He is here, you can ask again later if you think of it." He then ordered: "First pass on the Liu Wu family."
Fan Chunren, who was watching from the sidelines, saw Zhang Fei sweating profusely and couldn't help laughing: "Maybe you were right before, but this also proves that as long as you change the interrogation method, your method will no longer work."
Zhang Fei suddenly had an idea and chuckled: "I can't do it? If Fan Sijian can guarantee that I won't be beaten later, I can turn the situation around right away and nail Huang Yongli directly."
Fan Chunren was very curious and asked: "What are you going to do?"
Zhang Feiyun said calmly: "I'll just shout a few words. That's enough."
Fan Chunren really didn’t believe it. You could make a comeback by just shouting a few words. Do you think you are a god? He thought to himself that shouting a few words would not be a big crime, so he nodded and said, "Okay! If you just shout a few words,
, I promise you won’t be beaten.”
"Watch it! Don't blink!"
After Zhang Fei said that, he rushed over, jumped up, and cursed angrily: "Huang Yongli, you are worse than a pig or a dog! In order to sell your house, you did not hesitate to kill your own mother. A murderer, you are a murderer."
Mother murderer."
Everyone was shocked when he yelled.
Murderer?
Kill your mother?
real or fake?
One of the officials reacted first and quickly called to the government officials, "Stop him, stop him quickly!"
Immediately, two government servants rushed over and stopped Zhang Fei. While struggling, Zhang Fei shouted: "Huang Yongli, you beast. In the past two years, your mother has suffered from illness and pain, but you beast have turned a blind eye."
, you didn’t even invite a doctor, it turned out that you just wanted your mother to die early so that you could sell the house as soon as possible.”
Huang Yongli suddenly panicked and subconsciously retorted: "I didn't! You wronged me!"
You idiot. Zhang Fei yelled: "I wronged you? Have you ever taken your mother to see a doctor? Have you spent money on your mother's medical treatment? You are really a beast worse than a pig or a dog. For money, even your mother's
Even your life can be harmed. But you didn’t expect that Granny Huang has seen through your mind a long time ago. She would rather give the house to others than to you. She will make you angry to death. Haha, retribution, retribution! Hahaha!”
Liang Dong also reacted and was furious, "How did this guy get in? Get him quickly. It's really unreasonable. You dare to act wildly in my court. I have to do it today!"
"Sorry! Sorry!"
Fan Chunren suddenly ran over and gasped: "Liang Siru, I brought him in and disturbed Liang Siru's trial. I'm really sorry. I'll take him away now."
When Liang Dong looked at Fan Chunren, he had to look at the face of the Buddha as well as the monk. The key point is that he is Si Jian, who specializes in impeaching officials. This favor must be sold no matter what. He coughed: "Fan Si Jian, take him out of here quickly."
"
"Yes, yes, yes! Someday Fan will come again to apologize."
Fan Chunren repeatedly handed over his hand, feeling very guilty, and then pulled Zhang Fei outside, teaching him a lesson as he walked.
Zhang Fei, who was not listening, turned around and winked secretly at Xu Zhiqian.
When he got out of the door, Fan Chunren said excitedly: "You have wronged me."
Zhang Fei defended: "Why did I wrongly accuse someone? Didn't Fan Sijian hear just now? He admitted that it was for money. Then Fan Sijian, think about it. His mother died of illness. Who is the biggest beneficiary? He can finally
I got the house I wanted."
Fan Chunren said: "You are just speculating, there is no evidence."
Zhang Fei nodded and said, "I'm just guessing that Liang Siru won't listen to me either! Haha."