My opinion on a book friend's point of view Bingcheng Chenchen
Posted by: Bingcheng Chenchen
I think my level is limited, so I rarely post. Of course, this is my personal habit. I am not trying to explain anything. Please don’t misunderstand me. But today I want to post this post to discuss the views of the "wandering scholar". Take a look at me.
Does what you say make sense?
Only when the population is large, the quality of the land is poor, and the output cannot meet the needs of survival, will there be a desire to expand externally. This is a so-called "transformation" (the attitude towards things will be greatly changed.
), and Chinese farmers have become accustomed to sticking to their fields and cultivating intensively to change the situation of relying on the sky for food, and the feudal ethical ethics are deeply rooted in their bones.
However, the current land of the Song Dynasty can fully meet people's survival needs under the condition of intensive cultivation. If they continue to fight foreign wars, the farming population will drop sharply and fall into militarism. You let the mice, under such conditions of the country and the people, start to
If you advocate foreign expansion, will the farmers support you? Will the landlords and nobles respond to you? Will the officials in the DPRK support you?
Yes, you conquer a region and then immigrate or enslave the local indigenous people. But have you ever thought about what kind of neighbors and land are around the Song Dynasty now? In the eyes of the Central Plains people, it is a four-barbaric wilderness, and the idle population from there
To open up wasteland? Human life needs a cyclical system, that is, in addition to farm work, it also needs supporting supporting services such as trade fairs and so on. Do you calculate how many people will need to immigrate? How many troops and government officials will be needed to manage slavery?
Such a supporting system is like a country. Let’s not talk about whether there is support from anyone. Even if there is, then when it develops, does it still need to have a subordinate relationship with the Song Dynasty?
The foreign plunder you mentioned, what is the population of Spain? How many resources are needed? Send a hundred or ten people and two broken boats to go out for a while, and what they bring back is equivalent to how many years of their production value? If the rats send people out, how many people will they send?
Is it appropriate? There are not enough people to rob, but these soldiers are stuffed with teeth. If the things they get back are distributed to the people, not to mention the people, but also to the people who support this plundering war, how much benefit can they get? Give it to a soldier.
Divide the situation into two chicken tails? If you send more people, it will return to the situation mentioned above, from your deployment to a neighbor, and then after a few years, it will grow stronger, and then fight back, causing another disaster to your descendants?
Because Mo Zi is a time-travelling person, he has a clear understanding of the thoughts and state of his own nation and ancestors. So he can only figure it out slowly. Maybe his descendants can strive to expand externally. But it is definitely not his generation.
Letting him engage in Great Leap Forward-style development will only accelerate his demise.
I actually think that after a few years of concentrated operation, the Age of Discovery can be brought ahead of schedule, and the maximum benefit can be obtained at the minimum cost. This is the way to go in reality and is reliable. Use cheap folk kiln porcelain and ordinary porcelain
Silk fabrics can be exchanged for gold, silver, gemstones, ivory, grain crop seeds, fine horses, spices, etc.
Why was there the Opium War? It was because the trade was seriously unbalanced at that time. Most of the world's silver and resources were in China, so the invaders figured it out. So what about the current era of rats? Send out labor expeditions to the "four fields"
"The wilderness" has been conquered. Since they can't be allowed to extract oil, how about grabbing some trivial things? After these big-headed soldiers arrived at these places, they saw a desolate land, which was the place they fought for in the next few years. They were allowed to scold them.
Their ancestral graves are filled with smoke.
There is still a large area of land that can be developed in the northwest. Has anyone said that a large number of immigrants are needed? How much effort did it take to mobilize the immigrants for the Three Gorges Dam? How much manpower and material resources were spent?