The lawyer said: "Plaintiff, what do you think about the defendant's defense?"
Qin Hanlin said: "Presiding Judge, we have no objection and agree to the defendant's request for re-identification of the contract signatures."
Since Lin Peng's identification results in the previous lawsuit were overturned by two top experts and a carbon isotope detector, Qin Hanlin was unable to defend Lin Peng's handwriting identification results.
After all, if you make a major mistake in your appraisal, people will certainly have reason to question it.
And since Mingyu Company is sure that the contract is signed by Fang Wenfei, it doesn't matter if it is re-identified.
If it's true, it can't be false, just go through the identification process again.
The lawyer said: "Since both of you have no objections, the legal court agrees to re-evaluate the contract signature submitted by the plaintiff."
"According to regulations, Lin Peng, the appraiser of the first instance of this case, will no longer appear as the appraiser of the second instance."
"This court has invited other handwriting appraisal experts from the municipal judicial appraisal department to serve as professional appraisers for the second instance."
"In order to avoid possible errors caused by a single person's appraisal, there were three handwriting appraisal experts in the second trial. Through multiple rounds of appraisals, the combined opinions were used as the final appraisal result of the second trial."
"Plaintiff, Defendant, what do you think?"
Qin Hanlin said: "President, we have no objection."
Ren Chaoyu said: "Presiding Judge, we have an opinion."
The lawyer was startled, then showed a surprised expression and asked: "Defendant, have you invited a higher-level expert?"
Ren Chaoyu said: "Yes, presiding judge, we have invited authoritative experts in handwriting identification and micro-mark identification from the national forensic identification department to specifically identify the evidence in this case. Please allow the court to invite experts to the court."
I'll go... Everyone's faces were shocked.
Another national expert! Are top experts just Chinese cabbage?
Is it so easy to invite experts to do appraisals for ordinary civil litigation cases?
Lu Youwei was shocked and confused.
Chen Hao specially invited national experts to do signature and handwriting appraisal.
Does he think Fang Wenfei's signature on the contract is fake?
On second thought, is this not impossible?
After all, Fang Wenfei must have believed that she had never signed that contract, and when she told Chen Hao with all her heart, Chen Hao, a fanatical fan, would of course believe it.
Haha, this is interesting.
"Asking national experts to verify the genuine signature...Chen Hao, are you shooting yourself in the foot?"
Lu Youwei thought proudly, and couldn't help but turn his head to look in the direction of Chen Hao in the audience.
This time Chen Hao's eyes met his.
The two looked at each other and smiled.
"You are still laughing when you are so evil?
You think I am on the first floor, but actually I am on the third floor.
When the appraisal is over, you should cry!"
Lu Youwei sneered in his heart.
The lawyer said: "Since there is a more authoritative national handwriting appraisal expert, it is of course better. Please come to the court as soon as possible."
"Thank you, Judge."
Ren Chaoyu turned and left.
After a while, she and Fang Hua returned to Luting.
"Teacher Fang Hua!"
"It's you."
"It's really unexpected."
When the lawyer and others saw Fang Hua, they immediately showed surprise, stood up one after another, walked down from the trial seat, and greeted Fang Hua warmly.
Fang Hua shook hands one by one and said with a smile: "Zheng Luguan, Ma Luguan, Xiao Li... long time no see."
Ren Chaoyu said: "Presiding judge, do you know him?"
The lawyer smiled and said: "Of course, Teacher Fang is the leading micro-mark identification master in the country. We have several major and important cases, and we were able to solve them all because of Teacher Fang's help."
It's quite commendable.
Fang Hua waved his hands and said modestly: "That's what I should do."
A judge asked out of curiosity: "Teacher Fang, how come you are able to conduct appraisals on this case?"
You know, Fang Hua's qualifications and status are much more important than the carbon isotope detector of the forensic identification department.
The cases that Fang Hua can be asked to identify are all major and important cases of the highest level.
Asking Fang Hua to appraise an ordinary civil litigation case like this feels like asking a commander to handle a dispute between two ordinary soldiers.
Fang Hua smiled and said nothing.
The lawyer reacted quickly and immediately realized what was happening and said, "Xiao Ma, don't ask any more questions."
The judge surnamed Ma also realized something and said quickly: "I'm sorry, Teacher Fang, I'm too talkative."
Fang Hua shook his head, saying it didn't matter, and then took out his ID: "Law Officer Zheng, please check your ID."
"good."
The lawyer and others quickly checked the documents, returned them to Fang Hua, and said, "Teacher Fang, please come to the verification seat."
Fang Hua walked to the central platform.
The clerk opened the case file, took out the signed contract, and handed it to Fang Hua.
At the same time, Ren Chaoyu asked Fang Wenfei to sign on a blank A4 paper. After approval by the lawyer and others, he handed it over to Fang Hua for comparison.
Lu Youwei frowned slightly and whispered: "Lawyer Qin, do you think it's possible that Fang Hua was bribed by Fang Wenfei to do a fake appraisal?"
Although Fang Wenfei's signature was definitely authentic, he could not help but murmur in his heart when he saw the lawyer and others showing respect and enthusiasm to Fang Hua.
Qin Hanlin shook his head and said: "It would be possible for an ordinary handwriting appraiser, but it is absolutely impossible for a well-known and authoritative master like Fang Hua."
"Why?"
"The more famous you are, the more you will cherish your feathers. What's more, when you reach Fang Hua's level, you already have no shortage of fame and fortune. How can you accept bribes and make fake appraisals in ordinary civil litigation cases?
Isn’t this self-destructive?”
"makes sense."
Lu Youwei was stunned, and then sarcastically said: "Chen Hao hired such a well-known master to do an appraisal. It must have cost a lot of money, but the result of the appraisal made him bleed. Don't you think this is paying for the pain?"
,Hahaha."
He laughed.
Qin Hanlin did not speak, but frowned.
Chen Hao invited Fang Hua, obviously to make the final decision.
After all, no one is more authoritative than Fang Hua in handwriting appraisal.
This means that Chen Hao is absolutely sure, which is completely contrary to what the company thinks... After a moment, Fang Hua put down the contract and the A4 paper, raised his head and said: "Presiding judge, I have finished the appraisal."
The lawyer said: "Teacher Fang, what is the result of the appraisal?"
Fang Huadao: "Although the signature on the contract is somewhat similar to Ms. Fang Wenfei's on-site signature, the handwriting characteristics, stroke matching proportions, and text layout are completely different. It can be determined that the signature on the contract is not Ms. Fang Wenfei's."
He was a little surprised because the handwriting of the two signatures was so easy to tell that they were different. Even ordinary people, not to mention handwriting experts, could tell the difference after looking carefully for a while.
Asking him to do this kind of appraisal is equivalent to testing a college student's addition and subtraction within ten.
Fang Hua actually noticed the difference at first glance, but he just thought it was too easy and missed some details, so he watched it for a while.